Water-vs-Water /Compatibility???????

This topic was created in the Cancer forum by piggytoo240 on Sunday, December 25, 2011 and has 19 replies.
Hey guys!

I thought this would be a good question to ask. And would love to hear what the water sign family has to say regarding their experiences.
1. How deeply do you/did you feel a connection with your water mate.
2. Did you find that you are/was too much alike.
3. Did you feel emotionally burned out.
4. Did you feel as though you were just in love with yourself because you are so much alike.
And the big question;
5.How did you feel when you realized that we can't manipulate each other as we do others.
Have fun answering because I had a good laugh to myself thinking about these questions and my past experiences. We have to learn to to just take chances,expect something in return whether it be Good/Bad. And accept the things we cannot change.

Words Of Wisdom (Live, Laugh, Love )
Life is too short. Love yourself first,because if you don't love you. How will someone else know how to.
Tell the people you love the proper way you want to be loved.

Merry Christmas! Everyone.

yea taking showers are great its call good hygiene lmao.
Water with Water? As in Cancer woman and Pisces man?
No, no, no!!
It's an awful match, just won't work!!!
smile smile smile
Wow, loaded questions!! haha Hmmm, will think this over carefully, I have the answers they just are complex. May end up being one to two word answers just so I don't go swimming too deep lol This coming from dealing with Scorpio boys ya know Winking lol
Posted by DazedScorp
Never been with water....


Feel lucky. Unbelievably awesome, but hair pulling.
Posted by DazedScorp
Even golden showers?



does peeing in shower counts lmfao.
LOL.... This post is for compatibility between water signs...as in couples,friendships,ect. Hmmmm some of us get it....some us don't. Big Grin
Water signs have been the best for me in terms of relationships and friendships...sure a couple didn't work out but for only a bigger and better water man to come along anyway...smile
I prefer water because I don't have to keep explaining myself like I do with earth signs etc lol...I can be me moody and if the need arises clingy and detached all rolled up into one and my Pisces just gets me...perfect smile
Water we connect effortlessly and beautifully...I'm a Pisces with my gentleman Pisces for nearly 6 months now... before that a Cancer... intense fast but a short time and before that Pisces for 12 years...
Pisces and Pisces mind read connection...one thinking other speaks it etc etc...loving ...caring...and my Pisces can handle my bad points ahaha...that's the loyalty of a Pisces anyway...
So yes compatible but if they have too much air/fire in.. say their moon sign...not for me...too flighty...won't like me switching from detached to clingy etc...will feel smothered...and probably have one eyebrow up lol...I want loyalty through good and bad...and once they pass my bad trait test and still standing by me...they have me for eternity muhahaha...Big Grin
I might add with two same sign water...we already know what the other one is up to if/when they pull any tricks...kinda like 2 steps way ahead and can fit the end result perfect...so while the other may think they won...think again...haha...
ok that's sneaky but in a cute water way...not anything harmful...
So yes water cannot fool other water...unless clouded by emotions...hence the need to revert back to detachment at times...kinda of like the need for some air to breathe...compose oneself I guess...
Posted by piranhaparadiise
I might add with two same sign water...we already know what the other one is up to if/when they pull any tricks...kinda like 2 steps way ahead and can fit the end result perfect...so while the other may think they won...think again...haha...
ok that's sneaky but in a cute water way...not anything harmful...
So yes water cannot fool other water...unless clouded by emotions...hence the need to revert back to detachment at times...kinda of like the need for some air to breathe...compose oneself I guess...


Yeah, that's the thing that I always find humorous about Crab girls.
I am one of the FEW guys on the planet that they have a REALLY hard time fooling.
It's true about the psychic connection, as it is metaphysical in nature.
I can INSTANTLY tell when something is wrong with a Cancer female, especially if I have known her for a while.
1. How deeply do you/did you feel a connection with your water mate.


I felt a connection yes.I find most Pisces men in general have great connection with.
2. Did you find that you are/was too much alike.


Not at all it was quite the opposite.
3. Did you feel emotionally burned out.


Not at all.

4. Did you feel as though you were just in love with yourself because you are so much alike.


We were not very much alike, even as much as hair color, eye color etc.
We did share similar values though. Very important.
And the big question;
5.How did you feel when you realized that we can't manipulate each other as we do others.
click to expand


I did not try and manipulate him. It's not my thing..weird huh??? Buuut I knew I could easy..double weird.

Not sure how you other water signs are. I find more connection on a romantic, and mental level with Earth Signs. (thus far excluding Capricorns) And the same is true for that magnetism that just propels you to them.
Posted by piggytoo240

1. How deeply do you/did you feel a connection with your water mate.
2. Did you find that you are/was too much alike.
3. Did you feel emotionally burned out.
4. Did you feel as though you were just in love with yourself because you are so much alike.



1.) Don't want to be with anyone other than a Cancer female. The metaphysical connection is second to none.
2.) Never. I love the fact that we can speak telepathically with the passage of time.
3.) Never. It is very fulfilling to be with a human being who can communicate with me without even saying anything. It is a spiritual relationship that makes me feel warm inside.
4.) No, because Cancer is different than Pisces in some respects, but respects that I appreciate. Such as how Cancers know what to do in the kitchen, as opposed to my lesser skills therein.
You guys are beautiful people here on this forum. A lot of you give very good advise to others.

Just wanted to say thank you all for sharing.
Posted by piggytoo240
You guys are beautiful people here on this forum. A lot of you give very good advise to others.

Just wanted to say thank you all for sharing.


Thank you very much for the kind words!
Surely you don't limit yourself to just the advice around here, as there is such a delightful and savory amount of DRAMA to enjoy as well!
Posted by treefrogster
Posted by ScorpioFish
Water with Water? As in Cancer woman and Pisces man?
No, no, no!!
It's an awful match, just won't work!!!
smile smile smile


Confused Confused Confused
S N A ..... !!!!
Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin
click to expand


I get along with most water signs. My mother is a Scorp, sister a Pisces. Funny thing is that when were are together driving somehow we get turned around and lose sense of direction. LOL I'm usually the one driving and get distracted arguing politics with my sister and trying to pull any kind of response from my mother.
Never really seriously dated a water sign.
I dated a Cancer once,but it did not work out well. He was too clingy and babyish. It was not an awful relationship though. I feel like earth sign males understand me more honestly. I have a lot of earth sign male friends and I have been with a Virgo for 2 years. Sometimes I feel pairings of the same element will not work out too well,but then again I only know a few water signs not a lot unfortunately.
I appreciate my water sign friends though,the few that I actually do have lol.
Bumping for more responses.

Leave Your Feedback

We'd love to hear your thoughts! If you're not logged in, you can still share your feedback below. Your input helps us improve the experience for everyone. To post your own content or join the conversation, please log in or create an account.