Mac or Windows?

This topic was created in the Miscellaneous forum by Ram416 on Tuesday, August 29, 2017 and has 25 replies.
So next month I am getting some serious upgrades for my desktop and/or a high end laptop.

My question is, should I do that or get a Mac?

Some of my very basics as a user are :

Word processing

Gaming

Video/audio production

I've been told that only big wig companies now use Mac (for FCP) for post production purposes. Mac has been getting a lot of flak apparently for its lower end systems being sub par at best.

Any suggestions or opinions?
Posted by blvckphase
DON'T GET A MAC!!!!!
Lol why?

I've always wanted a Mac for video/audio production...But I've asked around in the industry and its turned out to be a disappointment.
Posted by seraph
Mac. Winking
Why though?
Posted by blvckphase
Posted by Ram416
Posted by blvckphase
DON'T GET A MAC!!!!!
Lol why?

I've always wanted a Mac for video/audio production...But I've asked around in the industry and its turned out to be a disappointment.
I don't know much about them in regard to gaming. I could never get passed the layout / navigating of a Mac.. I just don't like Apple anything, they are not very user friendly in my experience compared to Windows.. But I am also just stubborn and set in my ways.. LOL
click to expand
I think maybe Mac fails in the gaming dept. I dunno.

I'm not a fan of Mac either and I agree it's not very user friendly.

But I've seen/heard stuff done on a Mac (albeit this was 5 years ago) and oh my...

Are you a 50 y.old man with a goatee and a ponytail living in the 1990s?

If not, then just take a normal computer


Linux Tongue
Posted by seraph
Posted by Ram416
Posted by seraph
Mac. Winking
Why though?
Why not.

It's really your specific needs + personal preference in terms of interface and ecosystem.

Either one will do. But spend some time playing around with both Win and Mac machines and see which feels more like home. The "needs" part should be easy enough to figure out. Just determine the software/tools you need. Both platforms should have more or less what you're looking for unless it's a platform-specfic tool.
click to expand
I'm a multi platform user - Windows, Mac and Linux.

I was thinking of maybe getting a Mac for mostly video/audio.

I have Windows and Linux for the rest.
Posted by Zagittarius


Linux Tongue
Already have Linux on my laptop for my mixing. ?
Posted by seraph
Posted by Ram416
Posted by blvckphase
Posted by Ram416
Posted by blvckphase
DON'T GET A MAC!!!!!
Lol why?

I've always wanted a Mac for video/audio production...But I've asked around in the industry and its turned out to be a disappointment.
I don't know much about them in regard to gaming. I could never get passed the layout / navigating of a Mac.. I just don't like Apple anything, they are not very user friendly in my experience compared to Windows.. But I am also just stubborn and set in my ways.. LOL
I think maybe Mac fails in the gaming dept. I dunno.

I'm not a fan of Mac either and I agree it's not very user friendly.

But I've seen/heard stuff done on a Mac (albeit this was 5 years ago) and oh my...

You can game just fine on Macs, but they're not really for that. Some big-studio titles don't make it to Mac or only make it later. If gaming's a thing for you then you'll get much better value out of a Windows box.
click to expand
Yes I've heard about the delays in getting out the Mac version of games.
Posted by Tauruswithspunk
Windows computer (I have both brands)

but apple everything else. ❤️
You're a performer right?

Have you ever done any music mixing/ audio production work?
linux is dead, it never really took off because they never thought about improving the user experience and ease of use.

The only open source OS that has a chance to replace windows in the future is android.

Mac was never an option unless you like to pay 3X the price for a restricted hardware
Posted by Ram416
Posted by Zagittarius


Linux Tongue
Already have Linux on my laptop for my mixing. ?
click to expand
hehe.. i got linux and windows both in my laptop and office desk... i use linux for coding stuff and windows for graphical stuff and gaming... i hate apple products since 2010 ? lol Big Grin
Posted by seraph
Mac. Winking
I concur!

As someone who's used both for a long time, I prefer a Mac simply because it's less cumbersome overall. Doesn't take forever to power up and the security features are better.

PC Master Race gamers knows that you game on a PC with Windows.

Mac is definitely more for video/music production or as I did with my macbook, just web browse and check emails LOL

https://pcpartpicker.com/ is a good site to see what you can afford to build your little beast

Also, check out https://www.reddit.com/r/buildapc/ for deals and sales on PC parts, Monitors, etc.
Posted by ManInTheMoon
Hackintosh? Like with the new Amd cpus out you can make a banging computer that's future proof for less. If you need windows just dual boot. It's cumbersome but with an ssd it won't take long to boot. 30 sec max.
Music to my ears... AMD and SSD
Posted by Dreamyboy
I heard Mac is good for audio/video production. Personally, I don't know, but for gaming, it lacks support and requires stronger hardware for some reason. Maybe because of support and compatibility.

I'd rather get a win and custom it to work your way. Might cost the same as the Mac since Macs seem to cost an assload of money
Yeah I'm sticking to Windows for gaming, so now it's Mac mostly for video/audio production.
dont do mac, its going down hill. once was great not anymore. pc gaming computers can handle any graphic stuff a mac anymore. I love my msi computer. handles everything from game and my graphic design. i learn that some sciences use them for their simulations when they test a math thingy idea. both my laptop and desktop are msi motherboard computers. beef as alienware but haft the cost. LOVE IT. a lot of my gaming friends who do youtube videos use msi. you can ask any of them on the GG discord group i am in. the big thing is putting your money into a beefy graphics card. they run like hard drive now or like a small computer in the computer.


https://us.msi.com/


the next computer i sooo want to get is a quantum computer. YES crazy, love it

Mac and split the hardrive so you can run windows as well with paralells program
User Submitted Image
I would say Mac... They are supposed to be the best... But I can't afford one... So I wouldn't know... I have good experience with windows tho...
Posted by TurquoiseArrow
@Ram416

What are you mixing on linux?

or what software / hardware are you using...
https://www.mixxx.org/

I had a thread up once about Ubuntu
Posted by TurquoiseArrow
Posted by Ram416
Posted by TurquoiseArrow
@Ram416

What are you mixing on linux?

or what software / hardware are you using...
https://www.mixxx.org/

I had a thread up once about Ubuntu
I know that's why I was asking.

Did you ever get you turn table connected to it and working as you said you had issues with it?

click to expand
Yup I did! smile

I tried mixx on my windows PC but interestingly enough the windows version doesn't work as well as the Ubuntu one.
I hate how Windows is turning a computer into a smartphone. But I'd rather have PC over Mac.
Mac. My little bro is an audio engineer and a lot of companies make them use Macs
I've been a developer and designer for 20 years, so this is experience talking.

Forget what corporations are telling you, they need to sell things to make money. You'll be more than happy with an old "outdated" laptop, and install your choice of free Linux operating system:

https://www.howtogeek.com/191207/10-of-the-most-popular-linux-distributions-compared/

You don't need a faster processor and more RAM, you need a better operating system. I'm happily using a Toshiba laptop that's over 12 years old with Ubuntu, and it runs a lot faster and more reliably than any of the new laptops that have 4, even 8 times the speed.

But I do recommend replacing the old HDD with an SSD, the read/write rate does make a big difference.

And forget Microsoft Office, you'll be just fine with the free version of OpenOffice. It's faster, easier to use, and free.

Leave Your Feedback

We'd love to hear your thoughts! If you're not logged in, you can still share your feedback below. Your input helps us improve the experience for everyone. To post your own content or join the conversation, please log in or create an account.