reverting to Islam..

You are on page out of 3 | Reverse Order
Profile picture of ianthezuvis
ian
@ianthezuvis
8 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 99 · Topics: 2
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by sultrykitty
Jesus (pbuh). You don't "revert". You weren't born Muslim and then led astray. People aren't born with religion, they're taught it.
Wrong.


OK then, explain exactly how a newborn is Muslim. Do they face east to pray? Do they fast for Ramadan? Do they say the shahada?

click to expand

Everyone and everything is born Muslim in Islam.
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by sultrykitty
Jesus (pbuh). You don't "revert". You weren't born Muslim and then led astray. People aren't born with religion, they're taught it.
Wrong.


OK then, explain exactly how a newborn is Muslim. Do they face east to pray? Do they fast for Ramadan? Do they say the shahada?


Everyone and everything is born Muslim in Islam.
click to expand

What are the five pillars?

And explain how a baby fulfills them.

Profile picture of AA
AA
@AA
15 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 5545 · Topics: 162
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by AA
Islam is very simple, and it is more forgiving and flexible than people think. Resorting to trick questions catch somebody out is pointless, anyone can pay that game.
These aren't trick questions. They're simple questions that require the one being asked to apply simple logic.

click to expand

That's fair.

Have you googled?

How does one fast during Ramadan when they NEED to eat due to illness? Answer, you can eat, if you have intention and good will on the mind.

How does one pray when it is physically impossible? You can in mind with intention and good will.

Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by ianthezuvis
Muslims don't follow Muhammad.. they follow Allah..


Muslims follow Muhammad, end of. You have to accept that Allah speaks through Muhammad, that every command was relayed through him. That's why you have proscribed prayers, halal requirements, essentially Jewish Law (although somewhat corrupted), specific required recitations, ablution, etc. Allah didn't tell anyone but Muhammad to do these things. So you follow Muhammad.
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by AA
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by AA
Islam is very simple, and it is more forgiving and flexible than people think. Resorting to trick questions catch somebody out is pointless, anyone can pay that game.
These aren't trick questions. They're simple questions that require the one being asked to apply simple logic.


That's fair.

Have you googled?

How does one fast during Ramadan when they NEED to eat due to illness? Answer, you can eat, if you have intention and good will on the mind.

How does one pray when it is physically impossible? You can in mind with intention and good will.

click to expand

I didn't need to Google, studied Islam on my own for about about 10 years. From Islamic sources.

And yes, I'm aware of the things you mention. That doesn't absolve one of yhe requirements, only that you do it when you can.

Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by Senorita_LL
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by sultrykitty
Jesus (pbuh). You don't "revert". You weren't born Muslim and then led astray. People aren't born with religion, they're taught it.
Wrong.


OK then, explain exactly how a newborn is Muslim. Do they face east to pray? Do they fast for Ramadan? Do they say the shahada?


The father or a family elder will first whisper the call to prayer (adhan) in the baby's ear, shortly after it's birth.

This is one of the first thing, that Muslim will do.



click to expand

Ergo, not born Muslim. :-)

Profile picture of brianafay
brianafay
@brianafay
19 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 2454 · Posts: 30581 · Topics: 372
Posted by AA
Posted by brianafay
My thoughts are that religions aren't that different at their core

It all points back to the same god - just different interpretations and approaches due to culture and language

If you relate to Islam, great ??


That's a logical and intelligent theory, thought a lot about that one myself 🙂
click to expand


It's why I cannot be an atheist

Too much of the same story told different ways for me to discount it
Profile picture of HeavyEntertainmentShow
HeavyEntertainmentShow
@HeavyEntertainmentShow
8 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 4555 · Posts: 7614 · Topics: 100
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by sultrykitty
Jesus (pbuh). You don't "revert". You weren't born Muslim and then led astray. People aren't born with religion, they're taught it.
Wrong.


OK then, explain exactly how a newborn is Muslim. Do they face east to pray? Do they fast for Ramadan? Do they say the shahada?

click to expand

Don't bother. Religion & logic have never gotten along. He's lost the plot, just step away slowly and let him live out the rest of his life in blissful ignorance.
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by HeavyEntertainmentShow
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by sultrykitty
Jesus (pbuh). You don't "revert". You weren't born Muslim and then led astray. People aren't born with religion, they're taught it.
Wrong.


OK then, explain exactly how a newborn is Muslim. Do they face east to pray? Do they fast for Ramadan? Do they say the shahada?


Don't bother. Religion & logic have never gotten along. He's lost the plot, just step away slowly and let him live out the rest of his life in blissful ignorance.
click to expand

Lol sometimes I can't help myself. Call me crazy, it's kind of fun. I must have a masochistic streak. 😄

Profile picture of brianafay
brianafay
@brianafay
19 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 2454 · Posts: 30581 · Topics: 372
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by ellesbelles
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by Montgomery
Posted by ianthezuvis
any thoughts?
Is that like backsliding?


I don't understand


Maybe because you used the word "reverting"?

I am still confused because I thought it would be "converting".
I used the word revert on purpose...

click to expand


Because you've practiced Islam before ?
Profile picture of HeavyEntertainmentShow
HeavyEntertainmentShow
@HeavyEntertainmentShow
8 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 4555 · Posts: 7614 · Topics: 100
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by HeavyEntertainmentShow
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by ianthezuvis
Posted by sultrykitty
Jesus (pbuh). You don't "revert". You weren't born Muslim and then led astray. People aren't born with religion, they're taught it.
Wrong.


OK then, explain exactly how a newborn is Muslim. Do they face east to pray? Do they fast for Ramadan? Do they say the shahada?


Don't bother. Religion & logic have never gotten along. He's lost the plot, just step away slowly and let him live out the rest of his life in blissful ignorance.
Lol sometimes I can't help myself. Call me crazy, it's kind of fun. I must have a masochistic streak. 😄

click to expand

You probably have a fire Mars like me lol. Gross stupidity triggers me.
First
Previous
Next
Last