Solve this riddle

Profile picture of krysrenee7
krysrenee7
@krysrenee7
17 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 8735 · Topics: 522
Can you solve this riddle??

A rich and handsome man named James Leonard was murdered on a Sunday afternoon. At the time of the murder there was: the maid, the cook, the butler, the gardener and the wife.
Maid: I was fixing the table.
Cook: I was cooking breakfast.
Butler: I was sharpening knives in the kitchen.
Gardener: I was planting tomato seeds.
Wife: I was reading a book.

WHO DID IT?
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
Posted by krysrenee7
Can you solve this riddle??

A rich and handsome man named James Leonard was murdered on a Sunday afternoon. At the time of the murder there was: the maid, the cook, the butler, the gardener and the wife.
Maid: I was fixing the table.
Cook: I was cooking breakfast.
Butler: I was sharpening knives in the kitchen.
Gardener: I was planting tomato seeds.
Wife: I was reading a book.

WHO DID IT?



It was the Wife... because she was reading a book and new where all the others where at... as she had the power and position to also be the only one not seen by the others... and she did not really have to be anywhere...

The cook on the other hand with the knifes is directed at the people and their natural fears when they hear knife... read it or what ever lets their mind run wild...

PM
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
It also is the person telling the story so it is from their perspective... it is people natural reasoning you are telling the truth because of the way it was worded... but there is an element that this is not true and hypothetical... That is the only hole... as if it was a true... a police officer that was hopefully the right for the job as everyone has a reason for being 😉 is on the case and realize this is a perspective...

PM
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
Posted by piscesmoon2
Posted by krysrenee7
Can you solve this riddle??

A rich and handsome man named James Leonard was murdered on a Sunday afternoon. At the time of the murder there was: the maid, the cook, the butler, the gardener and the wife.
Maid: I was fixing the table.
Cook: I was cooking breakfast.
Butler: I was sharpening knives in the kitchen.
Gardener: I was planting tomato seeds.
Wife: I was reading a book.

WHO DID IT?



It was the Wife... because she was reading a book and new where all the others where at... as she had the power and position to also be the only one not seen by the others... and she did not really have to be anywhere...

The cook on the other hand with the knifes is directed at the people and their natural fears when they hear knife... read it or what ever lets their mind run wild...

PM
click to expand




Mean butler with the knifes... and the Cook was making breakfast because he was told to... The wife is the only one that could or was in the prime position to tell the others what to do other then maybe the butler and he would know where she was at... The wife would also normally have the most to gain... As it would do no real good to kill him... as they are not family really... as unless he wrote it even before them his money would go to next of kin...

PM
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
I think the wife had the most motive... Does not mean that there is an out of the box person... she had the easiest ability to do it...

Who knows maybe some nut got to him and no one saw... But if it had to be one of these I would start with her...

I would like to say... it was Sunday... and maybe they all had the day off... maybe they all live with him maybe they are all at home and she was the only one...

PM
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
Posted by MellyMel909
Oh FFS, it was the cook!

http://www.trickyriddles.com/riddle/5073-The-Murder-Mystery



If only if life things are that simple... after the wife I could see... him being next... then the butler... Who ever had the fishiest and most to gain... Normally most to gain because that is motive... That is why you have to find if anyone one of these people have motive first... If the cook just got fired then their you go... but why would wife not know that...


PM
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
Posted by krysrenee7
lol I love seeing how people really get deep into this & use all of their over-analyzing skills! And yes it was the COOK. The keyword was "Afternoon." The cook wouldn't have been making breakfast in the afternoon =)

At least now we know who the idiots are! LOL oh hush I was kidding =P



People sleep in... on Sunday... I don't by it... as it is Sunday and I have not eaten breakfast yet... and it is getting close to the afternoon... As I had a big dinner the other night... I had food coma... and went to bed at 9:30... I know crazy right...

It is ok... This is why text book answers are not always correct...

PM
Profile picture of firebunny
firebunny
@firebunny
14 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 99 · Posts: 16295 · Topics: 1686
Posted by krysrenee7
lol I love seeing how people really get deep into this & use all of their over-analyzing skills! And yes it was the COOK. The keyword was "Afternoon." The cook wouldn't have been making breakfast in the afternoon =)

At least now we know who the idiots are! LOL oh hush I was kidding =P



BUT THE WIFE TOLD HIM TO COOK BREAKFAST A DAY IN ADVANCE!!!! COULDN'T BE!!!!! @_@!!!!!
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
Posted by firebunny
Posted by krysrenee7
lol I love seeing how people really get deep into this & use all of their over-analyzing skills! And yes it was the COOK. The keyword was "Afternoon." The cook wouldn't have been making breakfast in the afternoon =)

At least now we know who the idiots are! LOL oh hush I was kidding =P



BUT THE WIFE TOLD HIM TO COOK BREAKFAST A DAY IN ADVANCE!!!! COULDN'T BE!!!!! @_@!!!!!
click to expand




Or that...

PM
Profile picture of krysrenee7
krysrenee7
@krysrenee7
17 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 8735 · Topics: 522
Posted by piscesmoon2
Posted by krysrenee7
lol I love seeing how people really get deep into this & use all of their over-analyzing skills! And yes it was the COOK. The keyword was "Afternoon." The cook wouldn't have been making breakfast in the afternoon =)

At least now we know who the idiots are! LOL oh hush I was kidding =P



People sleep in... on Sunday... I don't by it... as it is Sunday and I have not eaten breakfast yet... and it is getting close to the afternoon... As I had a big dinner the other night... I had food coma... and went to bed at 9:30... I know crazy right...

It is ok... This is why text book answers are not always correct...

PM
click to expand




Omg you're being too technical. Riddles are meant for the imagination!

Had the riddle said, "He was enjoying a beautiful Sunday EVENING" & yet the cook said he'd been cooking BREAKFAST would you have still said, "Well technically I eat breakfast at night too?" I mean come on!

Yes, I get it. Some people eat breakfast in the afternoon or the evening, BUT generally breakfast is related to the MORNING. Always has been
Profile picture of firebunny
firebunny
@firebunny
14 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 99 · Posts: 16295 · Topics: 1686
Posted by krysrenee7
Posted by piscesmoon2
Posted by krysrenee7
lol I love seeing how people really get deep into this & use all of their over-analyzing skills! And yes it was the COOK. The keyword was "Afternoon." The cook wouldn't have been making breakfast in the afternoon =)

At least now we know who the idiots are! LOL oh hush I was kidding =P



People sleep in... on Sunday... I don't by it... as it is Sunday and I have not eaten breakfast yet... and it is getting close to the afternoon... As I had a big dinner the other night... I had food coma... and went to bed at 9:30... I know crazy right...

It is ok... This is why text book answers are not always correct...

PM



Omg you're being too technical. Riddles are meant for the imagination!

Had the riddle said, "He was enjoying a beautiful Sunday EVENING" & yet the cook said he'd been cooking BREAKFAST would you have still said, "Well technically I eat breakfast at night too?" I mean come on!

Yes, I get it. Some people eat breakfast in the afternoon or the evening, BUT generally breakfast is related to the MORNING. Always has been
click to expand




He does have a point though. :>
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
Posted by krysrenee7
Posted by piscesmoon2
Posted by krysrenee7
lol I love seeing how people really get deep into this & use all of their over-analyzing skills! And yes it was the COOK. The keyword was "Afternoon." The cook wouldn't have been making breakfast in the afternoon =)

At least now we know who the idiots are! LOL oh hush I was kidding =P



People sleep in... on Sunday... I don't by it... as it is Sunday and I have not eaten breakfast yet... and it is getting close to the afternoon... As I had a big dinner the other night... I had food coma... and went to bed at 9:30... I know crazy right...

It is ok... This is why text book answers are not always correct...

PM



Omg you're being too technical. Riddles are meant for the imagination!
click to expand




No you are being to technical because you are defending the technical answers... as for me I am thinking as to motive first then as to what they said...

What does the cook have to gain... he is just a cook and now he maybe out of a job...

Life is never that simple... people who commit murder normally do it as a crime of passion or some type of motive... The person with the best motive is the wife... as you stated that he was rich... Just be he was good looking does not mean she was in love... she could have been a lesbian for all we know... We just now know that she is rich... so she has the most to gain...

PM
Profile picture of firebunny
firebunny
@firebunny
14 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 99 · Posts: 16295 · Topics: 1686
Posted by tiziani
Posted by firebunny
Posted by tiziani
I liked firebunny's answer where the wife sent them all off to do other tasks.



yeah... perfect crime! and it's the cook that was made to answer because he appeared to have lied! #slickwife! 😛



Damn right, she promised him conjugals in jail to be the fall guy.
click to expand




No, dude. She didn't have to! #slickwife! 😛
Profile picture of firebunny
firebunny
@firebunny
14 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 99 · Posts: 16295 · Topics: 1686
Posted by tiziani
Posted by firebunny
Posted by tiziani
Posted by firebunny
Posted by tiziani
I liked firebunny's answer where the wife sent them all off to do other tasks.



yeah... perfect crime! and it's the cook that was made to answer because he appeared to have lied! #slickwife! 😛



Damn right, she promised him conjugals in jail to be the fall guy.



No, dude. She didn't have to! #slickwife! 😛



Damn she's cold 😛
click to expand




Fill in the details, dude! How did she kill her husband through the use of a gun?! What kind of gun did she use? Did she call 911 after she killed him?! 😛
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
Posted by xPurrrHisssx
Posted by piscesmoon2
Posted by krysrenee7
Posted by piscesmoon2
Posted by krysrenee7
lol I love seeing how people really get deep into this & use all of their over-analyzing skills! And yes it was the COOK. The keyword was "Afternoon." The cook wouldn't have been making breakfast in the afternoon =)

At least now we know who the idiots are! LOL oh hush I was kidding =P



People sleep in... on Sunday... I don't by it... as it is Sunday and I have not eaten breakfast yet... and it is getting close to the afternoon... As I had a big dinner the other night... I had food coma... and went to bed at 9:30... I know crazy right...

It is ok... This is why text book answers are not always correct...

PM



Omg you're being too technical. Riddles are meant for the imagination!




No you are being to technical because you are defending the technical answers... as for me I am thinking as to motive first then as to what they said...

What does the cook have to gain... he is just a cook and now he maybe out of a job...

Life is never that simple... people who commit murder normally do it as a crime of passion or some type of motive... The person with the best motive is the wife... as you stated that he was rich... Just be he was good looking does not mean she was in love... she could have been a lesbian for all we know... We just now know that she is rich... so she has the most to gain...

PM



LMAO. Dude, you are hilarious. I love that you even initial your posts where you're debating with someone over a riddle. 😛
click to expand




This message was approved by PM...

PM
Profile picture of firebunny
firebunny
@firebunny
14 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 99 · Posts: 16295 · Topics: 1686
Posted by tiziani
Posted by firebunny
Posted by tiziani
Lol I'd rather wash my hands of this whole affair. No slick wives for me.



lol. I was hoping you'd share with us whatever you've learned in the spy novels you read. lol.



in a spy novel, she'd be halfway across the world to Jordan by now and everyone would know it's her from day 1. They'd just have to stop her because she killed her husband in an effort to start World War 3 😉
click to expand




whoah... that's pretty fast! @_@ I thought it would have been a perfect crime! How did they know that early?! @_@
Profile picture of piscesmoon2
piscesmoon2
@piscesmoon2
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 243 · Posts: 2393 · Topics: 16
Posted by krysrenee7
looooool you guys are nuts!

The people who got the riddle wrong wanna suddenly attack me all of the sudden. lol Figures...Blame Krysrenee as always lol



I did not blame you as you did not write the riddle... You simply posted it as a way to have a conversation...

I think it was successful and enjoyed it... thank you for sharing...

Don't be so hard on yourself...

PM
Profile picture of krysrenee7
krysrenee7
@krysrenee7
17 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 8735 · Topics: 522
Posted by firebunny
Posted by krysrenee7
looooool you guys are nuts!

The people who got the riddle wrong wanna suddenly attack me all of the sudden. lol Figures...Blame Krysrenee as always lol



I don'ts attack you but your riddle is da*n boring... I vant more action!
click to expand




Well bring something to the table then!!! Don't talk sh**t if you can't bring something better!!!!! *Imagines you taking that as a challenge....watches you start googling for good riddles* lmao j/k