Tulsa officer will be exonerated? Question mark

You are on page out of 3 | Reverse Order
Profile picture of Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
@Ophiuchus
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 18 · Posts: 629 · Topics: 16


The guy walks from behind his vehicle all the way to the driver side. As soon as he placed his hands on the window, one officer shot him, and another tazed him.

From the officiers' point of view, they can't see that the window is up, they're in a line south of the car. It isn't an unreasonable assumption to make that he was about to reach through the driver window to get a weapon. Why else would he walk all the way up there and not just put his hand on the back of the vehicle? This is the officers' point of view.

They both responded at the same time to what could have been perceived as a threat, only difference is one had a tazer and one actually had a gun, she certainly needed more training. She used excessive force and is wrong, but I can understand why she paniced. If this is explained she could be exonerated, or have her charge reduced.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2016/09/22/tulsa-officer-who-fatally-shot-terrence-crutcher-charged-with-first-degree-manslaughter/?utm_term=.786d5b67cf68

Wood told the Tulsa World that Shelby opened fire and that another officer used a stun gun when Crutcher’s “left hand goes through the car window.”

What do you guys think?
Profile picture of rockyroadicecream
rockyroadicecream
@rockyroadicecream
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 1243 · Posts: 16617 · Topics: 170
What I don't understand is if they're telling him to fucking stop, why does he keep walking to the car, disregarding them?

In so many of these situations, the one having the gun pointed at is fucking with those holding the gun. Why the fuck do people do such stupid shit when there's a gun pointed at them?

No, it's not right that they're getting shot, but jfc, you'd think you would completely cooperate when a fucking gun is pointed at you, because, hello? Gun is bad.
Profile picture of Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
@Ophiuchus
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 18 · Posts: 629 · Topics: 16
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus
Posted by GetMisted
What crime was he suspected of committing?
Once again my thread went completely over your head.
You asked me what I thought.. did you not?

I'm thinking you don't understand constitutionally protected rights.

What crime did she suspect him of committing in order for her to lawfully order him to stop and put his hands up?

click to expand

Why do you think they both reacted when he went up to the driver side? Do you think she will be exonerated?
Profile picture of Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
@Ophiuchus
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 18 · Posts: 629 · Topics: 16
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by rockyroadicecream
What I don't understand is if they're telling him to fucking stop, why does he keep walking to the car, disregarding them?

In so many of these situations, the one having the gun pointed at is fucking with those holding the gun. Why the fuck do people do such stupid shit when there's a gun pointed at them?

No, it's not right that they're getting shot, but jfc, you'd think you would completely cooperate when a fucking gun is pointed at you, because, hello? Gun is bad.
It's an unlawful order.

Cop: Hey you! Stop and put your hands up!

Me: Why?

Cop: I SAID SO! PUT YOUR HANDS UP!

Me: What crime did I commit??

Cop: *points gun at me*

Me: yeah.. fuck you buddy. You're gonna have to shoot me. I don't give up my rights that easily.

It's an unlawful order.

Rapist: Hey you! Give me sex!

You: Hell no!

Rapist: DO IT NOW! GIVE IT TO ME!

You: Are you foreal??

Rapist: *points gun at you*

Are you going to comply?
click to expand

But the law is far from perfect. This rights things isn't some invincible shield. If you're being raped at gunpoint, it's better to take the rape than lose your life. If you're being asked by a cop to stop at gun point, whether the cop is right or wrong, you don't go anywhere. These are basic survival tactics, forget the law for a moment and do what you can to preserve your life. After all is said and done, report the rapist, or sue the officer. Live to get your rights another day.

After reading that, I actually fear for your life. Take care.
Profile picture of Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
@Ophiuchus
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 18 · Posts: 629 · Topics: 16
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by rockyroadicecream
What I don't understand is if they're telling him to fucking stop, why does he keep walking to the car, disregarding them?

In so many of these situations, the one having the gun pointed at is fucking with those holding the gun. Why the fuck do people do such stupid shit when there's a gun pointed at them?

No, it's not right that they're getting shot, but jfc, you'd think you would completely cooperate when a fucking gun is pointed at you, because, hello? Gun is bad.
It's an unlawful order.

Cop: Hey you! Stop and put your hands up!

Me: Why?

Cop: I SAID SO! PUT YOUR HANDS UP!

Me: What crime did I commit??

Cop: *points gun at me*

Me: yeah.. fuck you buddy. You're gonna have to shoot me. I don't give up my rights that easily.

It's an unlawful order.

Rapist: Hey you! Give me sex!

You: Hell no!

Rapist: DO IT NOW! GIVE IT TO ME!

You: Are you foreal??

Rapist: *points gun at you*

Are you going to comply?
But the law is far from perfect. This rights things isn't some invincible shield. If you're being raped at gunpoint, it's better to take the rape than lose your life. If you're being asked by a cop to stop at gun point, whether the cop is right or wrong, you don't go anywhere. These are basic survival tactics, forget the law for a moment and do what you can to preserve your life. After all is said and done, report the rapist, or sue the officer. Live to get your rights another day.

After reading that, I actually fear for your life. Take care.


You may be okay with giving up your rights, be it constitutionally protected rights.. or in the case of rape, basic human rights.. but I am not.

I will never understand people's need to give up their rights in exchange for security or convenience.

click to expand

To preserve your life...? What good are rights if you're dead? And I never said to just let it be. I said after the situation has calmed down and you're safe make a report/sue. You can get your rights another day and keep your life. win win. Reacting emotionally/impulsively is not the best thing to do in these situations.
Profile picture of brianafay
brianafay
@brianafay
19 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 2454 · Posts: 30581 · Topics: 372
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by rockyroadicecream
What I don't understand is if they're telling him to fucking stop, why does he keep walking to the car, disregarding them?

In so many of these situations, the one having the gun pointed at is fucking with those holding the gun. Why the fuck do people do such stupid shit when there's a gun pointed at them?

No, it's not right that they're getting shot, but jfc, you'd think you would completely cooperate when a fucking gun is pointed at you, because, hello? Gun is bad.
It's an unlawful order.

Cop: Hey you! Stop and put your hands up!

Me: Why?

Cop: I SAID SO! PUT YOUR HANDS UP!

Me: What crime did I commit??

Cop: *points gun at me*

Me: yeah.. fuck you buddy. You're gonna have to shoot me. I don't give up my rights that easily.

It's an unlawful order.

Rapist: Hey you! Give me sex!

You: Hell no!

Rapist: DO IT NOW! GIVE IT TO ME!

You: Are you foreal??

Rapist: *points gun at you*

Are you going to comply?
click to expand

You cannot compare a rapist to a police officer .

Yes - it is your right to remain silent, your right to not consent to a search, your right to know what crime you are being suspected of...but it is not your right, not is it wise, to physically resist when asked to stop.

I am outraged by the lack of accountability, common manners and human decency of many cops but cops wouldn't be shooting people out of fear if they behaved in a rational compliant manner.

You won't see my ass on the news getting shot because of a police officer asks me to stop, I'm going to stop.

If I feel I am being wronged and treated unjustly I will handle it properly after the fact. That's what rational people do.

Its just sort of ignorant and unreasonable to say "you're gonna have to shoot me if you want me to comply"

And if you get your wish, are we supposed to riot on your behalf—





Profile picture of Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
@Ophiuchus
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 18 · Posts: 629 · Topics: 16
Posted by brianafay


You cannot compare a rapist to a police officer .

Yes - it is your right to remain silent, your right to not consent to a search, your right to know what crime you are being suspected of...but it is not your right, not is it wise, to physically resist when asked to stop.

I am outraged by the lack of accountability, common manners and human decency of many cops but cops wouldn't be shooting people out of fear if they behaved in a rational compliant manner.

You won't see my ass on the news getting shot because of a police officer asks me to stop, I'm going to stop.

If I feel I am being wronged and treated unjustly I will handle it properly after the fact. That's what rational people do.

Its just sort of ignorant and unreasonable to say "you're gonna have to shoot me if you want me to comply"

And if you get your wish, are we supposed to riot on your behalf—


My faith in dxpnet has been restored.
Profile picture of brianafay
brianafay
@brianafay
19 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 2454 · Posts: 30581 · Topics: 372
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus


To preserve your life...? What good are rights if you're dead?
What good is life if you have no basic rights?


You just quoted that part, quote my whole reply and read it again... get your rights ANOTHER DAY. Jesus Christ I'm done with you.
Say you're arrested for a crime you didn't commit. You're put in jail without bail or a bail too high for you to afford. You spend 3-4 years in jail awaiting trial before you can be proven guilty/innocent.

Let's also say that you're the main source of income for your family. Wife is at home taking care of your new born baby and a 5 year old.

How do they survive while you're awaiting trial?
click to expand

What is resisting going to accomplish though? Really?

They're gonna say "oh, shit we got a harass on our hands, you're free to go, sorry sir"??
Profile picture of brianafay
brianafay
@brianafay
19 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 2454 · Posts: 30581 · Topics: 372
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by brianafay
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus


To preserve your life...? What good are rights if you're dead?
What good is life if you have no basic rights?


You just quoted that part, quote my whole reply and read it again... get your rights ANOTHER DAY. Jesus Christ I'm done with you.
Say you're arrested for a crime you didn't commit. You're put in jail without bail or a bail too high for you to afford. You spend 3-4 years in jail awaiting trial before you can be proven guilty/innocent.

Let's also say that you're the main source of income for your family. Wife is at home taking care of your new born baby and a 5 year old.

How do they survive while you're awaiting trial?
What is resisting going to accomplish though? Really?

They're gonna say "oh, shit we got a harass on our hands, you're free to go, sorry sir"??


It's a lose/lose situation. Which is why this conversation needs to be had. Which is why people are fed up and rioting and protecting.

click to expand

I totally agree. Just not sure what destroying your home and lashing out at people who have nothing to do with it is going to accomplish either.

But I understand the anger and I am not one of those ignorant white people that pretends none of this is going on. I've seen it first hand.

People need to fight back without a doubt...but they need to do it properly and rationally...or the cycle continues

Profile picture of rockyroadicecream
rockyroadicecream
@rockyroadicecream
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 1243 · Posts: 16617 · Topics: 170
Posted by brianafay
Don't get me wrong, I think it's pathetic and despicable that these "professionals" are unable to keep their composure and are shooting people out of fear and/or frustration it seems...defiance by no means should be punishable by death...but in light of everything that has happened - why you would still resist and become a statistic is beyond me dudes
Exactly. Something some of the idiots around here seem to miss.

Too many "I can do whatever I want because I'm me" and less being a decent human being.

"I DON'T HAVE TO BECAUSE BLAH BLAH BLAH BLAH MEEEEE."

Fuck you.

This is what happens when you give everyone fucking trophies for gracing everyone with their presence and excuses are constantly made for bad behavior.

In a good portion of these stories making the news, most of those who were shot were being fucking stupid. This isn't even victim blaming, it's "why the fuck would you do that? Now you're dead!"

I'd also think that if you know some of these asshole cops are turning into trigger happy freaks, you'd REALLY want to cooperate to lower that risk and not be a statistic.
Profile picture of Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
@Ophiuchus
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 18 · Posts: 629 · Topics: 16
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus
Posted by GetMisted
At least if you resist and die..

Your family will get settlement money from your death.
You're measuring money alone... they'll get settlement money but lost a father/husband... why are you even putting a price on a life right now
I'm measuring my family's ability to survive without me.

If I comply.. sit in jail for 3-4 years awaiting trial.. do they survive? What if I get convicted of a crime I didn't commit?

If I resist and die... my family survives.
click to expand

You're being overly dramatic, as usual. Your family won't die if you're in jail for 3-4 years. They'll manage. After those 4 years you sue and you'll be compensated for the 4 years lost and your family will be well off AND have their father/husband. Think ahead please. You keep thinking in the moment.
Profile picture of VenusAquarius
"So I can show off my gold chain, gold ring. Roll through the hood on them gold thangs"
@VenusAquarius
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4341 · Posts: 13269 · Topics: 69
Posted by brianafay
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus


To preserve your life...? What good are rights if you're dead?
What good is life if you have no basic rights?


You just quoted that part, quote my whole reply and read it again... get your rights ANOTHER DAY. Jesus Christ I'm done with you.
Say you're arrested for a crime you didn't commit. You're put in jail without bail or a bail too high for you to afford. You spend 3-4 years in jail awaiting trial before you can be proven guilty/innocent.

Let's also say that you're the main source of income for your family. Wife is at home taking care of your new born baby and a 5 year old.

How do they survive while you're awaiting trial?
What is resisting going to accomplish though? Really?

They're gonna say "oh, shit we got a harass on our hands, you're free to go, sorry sir"??

click to expand

I'm blindly aware of my personal freedom, not a "badass," maybe a snotty bitch. And, I have exercised my freedom of speech and lawful action without being murdered by the cop in question. I didn't go to jail, didn't commit a crime, did have gun drawn on me, etc.



Did I just get lucky those times?
Profile picture of brianafay
brianafay
@brianafay
19 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 2454 · Posts: 30581 · Topics: 372
Posted by VenusAquarius
Posted by brianafay
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus


To preserve your life...? What good are rights if you're dead?
What good is life if you have no basic rights?


You just quoted that part, quote my whole reply and read it again... get your rights ANOTHER DAY. Jesus Christ I'm done with you.
Say you're arrested for a crime you didn't commit. You're put in jail without bail or a bail too high for you to afford. You spend 3-4 years in jail awaiting trial before you can be proven guilty/innocent.

Let's also say that you're the main source of income for your family. Wife is at home taking care of your new born baby and a 5 year old.

How do they survive while you're awaiting trial?
What is resisting going to accomplish though? Really?

They're gonna say "oh, shit we got a harass on our hands, you're free to go, sorry sir"??


I'm blindly aware of my personal freedom, not a "badass," maybe a snotty bitch. And, I have exercised my freedom of speech and lawful action without being murdered by the cop in question. I didn't go to jail, didn't commit a crime, did have gun drawn on me, etc.



Did I just get lucky those times?

click to expand

No, I would say you handled yourself properly.

It's fine to say, "I wish to remain silent"

It's fine to refuse a search

It's fine to demand to know why you are being stopped

I don't think any of that has ever gotten anyone shot. That's not threatening.

What's gotten people shot is acting sketchy as fuck and attempting to flee or physically resisting/fighting cops.

Profile picture of brianafay
brianafay
@brianafay
19 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 2454 · Posts: 30581 · Topics: 372
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by brianafay
There are also lots of grants for children of incarcerated parents...I know because my best friend growing up received them and got a full ride through college

But that's besides the point. I don't want to sound insensitive
Fair enough.

I want your honest opinion on something though..

Is it better..

To convicted an innocent person?

Or to allow a guilty person to walk and get them at a later date?
click to expand

Obviously the latter ...but things escalate out of control when you attempt to flee or resist ...cops are jumpy as hell and I can't say I don't understand why seeing the irrational way people act
Profile picture of Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
@Ophiuchus
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 18 · Posts: 629 · Topics: 16
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by brianafay
There are also lots of grants for children of incarcerated parents...I know because my best friend growing up received them and got a full ride through college

But that's besides the point. I don't want to sound insensitive
Fair enough.

I want your honest opinion on something though..

Is it better..

To convicted an innocent person?

Or to allow a guilty person to walk and get them at a later date?
click to expand



The latter.

Your mindset seems to be - if you don't fight the cops you're gonna be convicted, period.

What happened to all your rights talk? Be rational and exercise your rights in court after everything has happened and be exonerated. I don't get how you make a big deal about rights while a gun is pointed at you, but forget your rights exist anywhere else. It's like you're trying so hard to justify fighting the cops on the field and putting it up as the best course of action. What even
Profile picture of VenusAquarius
"So I can show off my gold chain, gold ring. Roll through the hood on them gold thangs"
@VenusAquarius
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4341 · Posts: 13269 · Topics: 69
Posted by brianafay
Posted by VenusAquarius
Posted by brianafay
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Ophiuchus


To preserve your life...? What good are rights if you're dead?
What good is life if you have no basic rights?


You just quoted that part, quote my whole reply and read it again... get your rights ANOTHER DAY. Jesus Christ I'm done with you.
Say you're arrested for a crime you didn't commit. You're put in jail without bail or a bail too high for you to afford. You spend 3-4 years in jail awaiting trial before you can be proven guilty/innocent.

Let's also say that you're the main source of income for your family. Wife is at home taking care of your new born baby and a 5 year old.

How do they survive while you're awaiting trial?
What is resisting going to accomplish though? Really?

They're gonna say "oh, shit we got a harass on our hands, you're free to go, sorry sir"??


I'm blindly aware of my personal freedom, not a "badass," maybe a snotty bitch. And, I have exercised my freedom of speech and lawful action without being murdered by the cop in question. I didn't go to jail, didn't commit a crime, did have gun drawn on me, etc.



Did I just get lucky those times?


No, I would say you handled yourself properly.

It's fine to say, "I wish to remain silent"

It's fine to refuse a search

It's fine to demand to know why you are being stopped

I don't think any of that has ever gotten anyone shot. That's not threatening.

What's gotten people shot is acting sketchy as fuck and attempting to flee or physically resisting/fighting cops.

click to expand

You would think so but, it's not true. St. Paul Minnesota...

Broken taillight...The officer asked her boyfriend for his license and registration, and that he told the officer he had a pistol and was licensed to carry.

“He was reaching for his wallet and the officer just shot him in his arm,” she says. “He shot his arm off."

People's constitutional rights are being violated. And, it shouldn't be a game of russian roulette to assert your rights whether consciously or subconsciously.

Even those who don't assert and actually give up their rights, "cooperate" are being assualted or murdered. It's scary.

Profile picture of VenusAquarius
"So I can show off my gold chain, gold ring. Roll through the hood on them gold thangs"
@VenusAquarius
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4341 · Posts: 13269 · Topics: 69
Posted by seraph
This is a basic common sense issue. You'd need to be pants-on-head stupid if you want to start fighting for your rights on the scene of a police encounter. You *can* do that, but you'll radically decrease your chances of making your lunch appointment with your head still on. If a police officer instructs you to stop walking, you stop walking, even if you think it is unlawful for them to make that request. They usually won't demand you to fellate them or do weird shit. In the vast majority of cases the demands come in the form of getting out of a vehicle, standing here or there, or to stop doing something that you can easily and safely stop doing. So we can cut the "rape" bullshit along with the "well what if they ask you to do *insert ridiculous thing that won't happen*, are you just going to do it??"

The question isn't whether what you're being told to do is lawful/unlawful, the question is where and when you will fight it if it is. Doing it on scene is not a good idea for obvious reasons.

You aren't giving up your rights. You're picking your battles. It's being smart about the situation.

How responsible is it for you to be confrontational with officers and start refusing simple instructions if you've got a child in the back seat? How responsible is it for you to be confrontational with officers and start refusing simple instructions if you've got a family at home that needs you to return safely to them?

You aren't being a hero and you aren't being courageous by beating your chest with police. Defending your significant other or your child from harm or harassment is one thing. Police giving you simple instructions is a completely different issue.

And no, rapists and police officers aren't the same, and to attempt to draw parallels is a false equivalence too hilarious to even contemplate.

In the vast majority of cases you're to comply with police. If you feel your rights have been violated there are mechanisms in place after the fact that can be used to address your concerns. If you don't like that you can always get stupid and see what happens. If you don't want cops messing with your rights there are other ways to make change happen and get the appropriate legislation passed.

De-escalation of a situation has to happen on both sides. The individual being given instructions is just as responsible for an easy, non-deadly outcome as the police officer.

Duh, people.
I am not premeditative with my freedom... It comes naturally. Period. I just live and let live.

No fight and in many cases there was no fight or assertion of rights.

Profile picture of Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
@Ophiuchus
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 18 · Posts: 629 · Topics: 16
Posted by seraph
This is a basic common sense issue. You'd need to be pants-on-head stupid if you want to start fighting for your rights on the scene of a police encounter. You *can* do that, but you'll radically decrease your chances of making your lunch appointment with your head still on. If a police officer instructs you to stop walking, you stop walking, even if you think it is unlawful for them to make that request. They usually won't demand you to fellate them or do weird shit. In the vast majority of cases the demands come in the form of getting out of a vehicle, standing here or there, or to stop doing something that you can easily and safely stop doing. So we can cut the "rape" bullshit along with the "well what if they ask you to do *insert ridiculous thing that won't happen*, are you just going to do it??"

The question isn't whether what you're being told to do is lawful/unlawful, the question is where and when you will fight it if it is. Doing it on scene is not a good idea for obvious reasons.

You aren't giving up your rights. You're picking your battles. It's being smart about the situation.

How responsible is it for you to be confrontational with officers and start refusing simple instructions if you've got a child in the back seat? How responsible is it for you to be confrontational with officers and start refusing simple instructions if you've got a family at home that needs you to return safely to them?

You aren't being a hero and you aren't being courageous by beating your chest with police. Defending your significant other or your child from harm or harassment is one thing. Police giving you simple instructions is a completely different issue.

And no, rapists and police officers aren't the same, and to attempt to draw parallels is a false equivalence too hilarious to even contemplate.

In the vast majority of cases you're to comply with police. If you feel your rights have been violated there are mechanisms in place after the fact that can be used to address your concerns. If you don't like that you can always get stupid and see what happens. If you don't want cops messing with your rights there are other ways to make change happen and get the appropriate legislation passed.

De-escalation of a situation has to happen on both sides. The individual being given instructions is just as responsible for an easy, non-deadly outcome as the police officer.

Duh, people.

Image Not Found
Profile picture of Montgomery
Montgomery
@Montgomery
12 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 552 · Posts: 18848 · Topics: 149
Posted by Ophiuchus


The guy walks from behind his vehicle all the way to the driver side. As soon as he placed his hands on the window, one officer shot him, and another tazed him.

From the officiers' point of view, they can't see that the window is up, they're in a line south of the car. It isn't an unreasonable assumption to make that he was about to reach through the driver window to get a weapon. Why else would he walk all the way up there and not just put his hand on the back of the vehicle? This is the officers' point of view.

They both responded at the same time to what could have been perceived as a threat, only difference is one had a tazer and one actually had a gun, she certainly needed more training. She used excessive force and is wrong, but I can understand why she paniced. If this is explained she could be exonerated, or have her charge reduced.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2016/09/22/tulsa-officer-who-fatally-shot-terrence-crutcher-charged-with-first-degree-manslaughter/?utm_term=.786d5b67cf68

Wood told the Tulsa World that Shelby opened fire and that another officer used a stun gun when Crutcher’s “left hand goes through the car window.”

What do you guys think?




I think this is the first thread I've seen representing

the other side, for the sake of giving both sides of

the story.

I like that.







Profile picture of VenusAquarius
"So I can show off my gold chain, gold ring. Roll through the hood on them gold thangs"
@VenusAquarius
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4341 · Posts: 13269 · Topics: 69
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by seraph


Duh, people.
You always says it's "common sense". It's not as black/white as you want to make it out to be.

When I was arrest for my DWI, it was 6 months before I even got into a courtroom to plead guilty. 6 months..

Obviously I was guilty.. I know that. I also had enough money to post bail and pay a lawyer to get my punishment reduced from a year in jail/ $ 2000 fine deduced to time served/ $ 400 fine.

Now...

Let's say that I was not guilty. Let's say I was also working a minimum wage job at the time.

I wouldn't have been able to post bail. I'd have set 6 months in jail while awaiting my day in court. If I would have been convicted (which probably would have happened with a public defender since I wouldn't be able to afford an attorney), that's another year in jail plus fines.. All the while not being able to work and make money to pay those fines. I'm left in a tough spot when I get out.

Now let's up the stakes.. You're arrested for a much more serious crime your innocent of. Except now you have a family also. You're going to spend even more time in jail before your court date, because the prosecutor needs the time to put his case together. Could be a year.. could be 4? Who knows. When you finally get to trial.. you're convicted! 10 years in the pen.

What does you're family do?

If you don't have the money to beat the system, you're shit out of luck.

You're common sense approach only helps if you have the means. $ $ $

The "mechanisms" you speak of do nothing to help those less fortunate.

click to expand

You're lucky... I've heard as much as 2 years.

Wondering if it has anything to do with the private prison contracts and private contractors?

Profile picture of Montgomery
Montgomery
@Montgomery
12 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 552 · Posts: 18848 · Topics: 149
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by seraph


Duh, people.
You always says it's "common sense". It's not as black/white as you want to make it out to be.

When I was arrest for my DWI, it was 6 months before I even got into a courtroom to plead guilty. 6 months..

Obviously I was guilty.. I know that. I also had enough money to post bail and pay a lawyer to get my punishment reduced from a year in jail/ $ 2000 fine deduced to time served/ $ 400 fine.

Now...

Let's say that I was not guilty. Let's say I was also working a minimum wage job at the time.

I wouldn't have been able to post bail. I'd have set 6 months in jail while awaiting my day in court. If I would have been convicted (which probably would have happened with a public defender since I wouldn't be able to afford an attorney), that's another year in jail plus fines.. All the while not being able to work and make money to pay those fines. I'm left in a tough spot when I get out.

Now let's up the stakes.. You're arrested for a much more serious crime your innocent of. Except now you have a family also. You're going to spend even more time in jail before your court date, because the prosecutor needs the time to put his case together. Could be a year.. could be 4? Who knows. When you finally get to trial.. you're convicted! 10 years in the pen.

What does you're family do?

If you don't have the money to beat the system, you're shit out of luck.

You're common sense approach only helps if you have the means. $ $ $

The "mechanisms" you speak of do nothing to help those less fortunate.

click to expand



Good point but thats a class issue more than

a race issue imo.





Profile picture of Montgomery
Montgomery
@Montgomery
12 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 552 · Posts: 18848 · Topics: 149
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by Montgomery
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by seraph


Duh, people.
You always says it's "common sense". It's not as black/white as you want to make it out to be.

When I was arrest for my DWI, it was 6 months before I even got into a courtroom to plead guilty. 6 months..

Obviously I was guilty.. I know that. I also had enough money to post bail and pay a lawyer to get my punishment reduced from a year in jail/ $ 2000 fine deduced to time served/ $ 400 fine.

Now...

Let's say that I was not guilty. Let's say I was also working a minimum wage job at the time.

I wouldn't have been able to post bail. I'd have set 6 months in jail while awaiting my day in court. If I would have been convicted (which probably would have happened with a public defender since I wouldn't be able to afford an attorney), that's another year in jail plus fines.. All the while not being able to work and make money to pay those fines. I'm left in a tough spot when I get out.

Now let's up the stakes.. You're arrested for a much more serious crime your innocent of. Except now you have a family also. You're going to spend even more time in jail before your court date, because the prosecutor needs the time to put his case together. Could be a year.. could be 4? Who knows. When you finally get to trial.. you're convicted! 10 years in the pen.

What does you're family do?

If you don't have the money to beat the system, you're shit out of luck.

You're common sense approach only helps if you have the means. $ $ $

The "mechanisms" you speak of do nothing to help those less fortunate.




Good point but thats a class issue more than

a race issue imo.








Have I mentioned race?

click to expand



So you agree.

Profile picture of LadyNeptune
LadyNeptune
@LadyNeptune
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 11076 · Posts: 35718 · Topics: 110
Posted by GetMisted
Anyone remember the Kinsey shooting in Miami? Wasn't too long ago..

The man complied. Laid on the ground with hands up. He was shot while officers were attempting to shoot the mentally disabled kid he was taking care of because they thought the toy train the kid was holding.. was a weapon.

No charges brought up on the officer.

I mean come the fuck on people.
Yeah I remember it. Disgusting abuse of power.

//www.youtube.com/embed/QAJRcRZPfwQ
Profile picture of LadyNeptune
LadyNeptune
@LadyNeptune
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 11076 · Posts: 35718 · Topics: 110
Posted by seraph
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by seraph


What are you talking about?

I'm not discussing exoneration of that officer. I'm addressing specifically what you posted earlier in the thread.
Let me rephrase this then..

How many innocent people must be sacrificed to make sure we get all of the "bad guys"?

Are YOU okay with being sacrificed for the greater good?


I have no idea what you're talking about. Are you ok?

All that is being said here (by *one* of us, anyway) is that it's preferable to simply comply with police requests. You don't know how a police encounter will go for certain (even though it'll probably go fine if you do your part), so even if there's this uncertainty, it's still a good idea to not act like an idiot. Even if you get a charge that you think is unjust it's *still* a good idea to not act like an idiot.

The rest you have no control over. All you can do anything about is what *you* are doing.
click to expand

This is exactly the problem...we have complying men that are being gun down because they are black.

First
Previous
Next
Last