Posted by Scorpio72
I've heard different opinions, read different articles. Just want your opinions of how you would take someone asking for a "break".
His sign Taurus Sun/Gemini Moon/Venus in Cancer
My sign Scorpio Sun/Aqua moon/Venus in Libra
Posted by P-AngelPosted by Scorpio72
I've heard different opinions, read different articles. Just want your opinions of how you would take someone asking for a "break".
His sign Taurus Sun/Gemini Moon/Venus in Cancer
My sign Scorpio Sun/Aqua moon/Venus in Libra
To clarify, I just wanted peoples' opinions on "breaks". If they agreed with them, if they didn't...that's all. I only put our signs because this is an astrology board...
Different opinions on why someone they don't know, and have only gotten two sentences about him to actually get where he comes from ... is completely irrelevant, and has no bearing whatsoever on why he wants to do something.
So, asking this question serves no purpose at all, except to fill you with imaginings you haven't thought of yet.
How illogical.click to expand
Posted by P-Angel
What you should be doing is asking yourself:
Why didn't I know he needed a break from me? I need to do a serious evaluation to find out how he could want a break from me, and it flew right over my head.
Posted by CluelessCancer
My opinion:
Very healthy as long as it's not long term!
it makes you assess your relationship, you, and him.
it's good thing to take a breather.
Posted by CluelessCancer
Also note, Taurus move mad slow, like turtles. Give him time. Be easy. Don't do anything a water sign will do. Just relax. Joke. Be happy.
Posted by kalin
I'd just get mad if someone says he needs a break
Posted by Scorpio72Posted by kalin
I'd just get mad if someone says he needs a break
My emotions are all over the place right now cause I just don't get it..and to be honest, I'm about tired of trying to understand it. I don't get how you can tell someone how crazy you are about them, how much you miss them when you're not with them and how they are your...to just turn around less than a week later saying you need a break from that very same person!! I just don't feel that he's being very forthcoming with what is actually going on, but the truth will come out soon enough so I'm just going to do my own thing for now and if he decides to come back around, I will then make the decision as to whether I want to continue with someone who seems to think my heart has a revolving door on it. Why do people not understand that when you ask for a break from them, that it changes the whole dynamics of any future the relationship has?? If you want out, just ask and I will open the door that you came in!click to expand
Posted by starlover
But dont men go into their cave from time to time (another word for break i guess)? Isnt it healthy to have time away from each other sometimes? Maybe you try and approach it differently, as in it is probably healthy and meant to be?
I have been asked for a break from my lover ~ it usually lasted for a day or two with him ~ no big deal ~ in fact i asked for one from him a while back and it lasted some time, but it didnt affect the relationship.
Just my observations
Posted by Scorpio72
Let's try this again....
To clarify, I just wanted peoples' opinions on "breaks". If they agreed with them, if they didn't...that's all. I only put our signs because this is an astrology board...
Posted by Scorpio72
I'm so glad that I'm not the only one who thinks he's being selfish.
click to expand
Posted by P-AngelPosted by Scorpio72
Let's try this again....
To clarify, I just wanted peoples' opinions on "breaks". If they agreed with them, if they didn't...that's all. I only put our signs because this is an astrology board...
One thing I have never been is "full of shit". And I DID want peoples opinions on breaks. I can call him out ony own if I need to, I dont need "back up" to do so. And please dont use the word "we" when you seem to be only speaking for you. No one else seems to have your same opinion. If he has left me, then fine. I only elaborated on the situation to give people a better idea of what is going on. I didnt come on here with bitterness. I only wanted opinions of "breaks" and how people viewed them.
You're so full of shit .. you didn't just ask this question to get opinions ... you posed this question to get people to agree with you, in calling this guy out.
In reality, nobody knows this guy and nobody knows the actual story .... we do know that you had no clue to him wanting to leave you.
Posted by Scorpio72
I'm so glad that I'm not the only one who thinks he's being selfish.
click to expand
Posted by Scorpio72
I'm not sleeping around nor is he. I just wanted to know if people here would ACCEPT a "break" or not...it's just that simple.
Posted by ninjutsu
Yeah I wouldn't be into a break if he wanted to use that time to "think about it". It's feasibly endurable if he's sorting himself or something in his life out, but if he wants time away from us to reflect -on us- then he can just cut the cord as far as I'm concerned.
Posted by aquapiscescusp
I would tell him to take a break as long as he wanted. Smile and walk away.
When he is finished with his break and he decides to call you, don't pick up.
Posted by ninjutsuPosted by Scorpio72Posted by ninjutsu
Yeah I wouldn't be into a break if he wanted to use that time to "think about it". It's feasibly endurable if he's sorting himself or something in his life out, but if he wants time away from us to reflect -on us- then he can just cut the cord as far as I'm concerned.
I know he's got alot going on in his life and that's why I was "Ok. Fine, take the time you need." at first. BUT what just did me in was him ignoring two of my texts during this break BUT I know for a fact, from previous times, that he would've gotten his panties in a wad IF I had ignored him Sunday night. NOBODY deserves to be ignored. NOBODY!!!!
Yeah, I don't blame you for having an issue with it, sounds as if he's well and truly opting out emotionally. Were they texts that really necessitated a response though?click to expand
Posted by ninjutsu
Well that insight should make it easier for you to let go at least, because that's a pretty unattractive trait in a person imo.. And yeah, you sent two texts over a generous time period so he could have acknowledged them. It's not like you were inundating him every five minutes..
Posted by PurrrrrrHissssss
Personally, the only time I've asked for a "break" was when a relationship was driving me completely nuts and I knew it wouldn't work out, but just didn't have the balls to permanently end it yet.
Posted by PurrrrrrHissssssPosted by Scorpio72Posted by PurrrrrrHissssss
Personally, the only time I've asked for a "break" was when a relationship was driving me completely nuts and I knew it wouldn't work out, but just didn't have the balls to permanently end it yet.
I would get that IF he had just said "I need a break" but he said "I need a break. Just a few weeks.". Why put a time limit on the break you're asking for IF you are intending it be a permanent break??? His Moon in Gemini will be the death of him and anyone that gets close to him....
I don't know. Did he sleep around much before you got together?
Yeah, Gemini moons scare me a little bit.click to expand
Posted by lualibra
you have to have GREAT communication and respect for each other to be able to differentiate between taking a break to heal the relationship or taking a break cause you're eyeballing that light at the end of the tunnel
Posted by Scorpio72Posted by lualibra
you have to have GREAT communication and respect for each other to be able to differentiate between taking a break to heal the relationship or taking a break cause you're eyeballing that light at the end of the tunnel
And me being a Libra, I'm the communicator trying to seek balance and justice. I just got tired of trying to get a straight answer out of him. I'm done trying...the ball is in his court now.click to expand
Posted by rockyroadicecreamPosted by Scorpio72Posted by lualibra
you have to have GREAT communication and respect for each other to be able to differentiate between taking a break to heal the relationship or taking a break cause you're eyeballing that light at the end of the tunnel
And me being a Libra, I'm the communicator trying to seek balance and justice. I just got tired of trying to get a straight answer out of him. I'm done trying...the ball is in his court now.
I thought you were a Scorp?click to expand
Posted by Scorpio72Posted by aquapiscescusp
I would tell him to take a break as long as he wanted. Smile and walk away.
When he is finished with his break and he decides to call you, don't pick up.
*Applause*
click to expand
Posted by Scorpio72Posted by kalin
I'd just get mad if someone says he needs a break
My emotions are all over the place right now cause I just don't get it..and to be honest, I'm about tired of trying to understand it. I don't get how you can tell someone how crazy you are about them, how much you miss them when you're not with them and how they are your...to just turn around less than a week later saying you need a break from that very same person!! I just don't feel that he's being very forthcoming with what is actually going on, but the truth will come out soon enough so I'm just going to do my own thing for now and if he decides to come back around, I will then make the decision as to whether I want to continue with someone who seems to think my heart has a revolving door on it. Why do people not understand that when you ask for a break from them, that it changes the whole dynamics of any future the relationship has?? If you want out, just ask and I will open the door that you came in!click to expand
Posted by MontgomeryPosted by Scorpio72Posted by kalin
I'd just get mad if someone says he needs a break
My emotions are all over the place right now cause I just don't get it..and to be honest, I'm about tired of trying to understand it. I don't get how you can tell someone how crazy you are about them, how much you miss them when you're not with them and how they are your...to just turn around less than a week later saying you need a break from that very same person!! I just don't feel that he's being very forthcoming with what is actually going on, but the truth will come out soon enough so I'm just going to do my own thing for now and if he decides to come back around, I will then make the decision as to whether I want to continue with someone who seems to think my heart has a revolving door on it. Why do people not understand that when you ask for a break from them, that it changes the whole dynamics of any future the relationship has?? If you want out, just ask and I will open the door that you came in!
I'm with you, and I don't think I would put it with it, generally speaking.
There might be some situations where that *may* make sense (though I can't think of any), but I think it is callous, and cruel, to boot.
It also implies an assumption that they will be welcomed back into your life, at *their* discretion-- not yours-- and an expectation that you put your life on hold while you wait for them to make up their mind.
Sorry that's happening in your world.click to expand
Posted by Scorpio72Posted by Montgomery
I'm with you, and I don't think I would put it with it, generally speaking.
There might be some situations where that *may* make sense (though I can't think of any), but I think it is callous, and cruel, to boot.
It also implies an assumption that they will be welcomed back into your life, at *their* discretion-- not yours-- and an expectation that you put your life on hold while you wait for them to make up their mind.
Sorry that's happening in your world.
Thank you. I do want to make it clear that I didn't post all this to get sympathy or help in bashing him. I bash him enough in my own head as it is.
I agree that by putting the "just a few weeks" with the "I need a break", just implies that I should wait. I did tell him at that time that I could not make any promises as to how I would feel when he was done with his "break", his response was "I'm not asking you to. I do understand.". I took a huge step the night before by deleting all of his texts, pics and contact info in my phone. I know that if I had the strength to take that big of a step, then I have enough strength to leap forward and leave him behind, permanently!click to expand
Posted by MontgomeryPosted by Scorpio72Posted by Montgomery
I'm with you, and I don't think I would put it with it, generally speaking.
There might be some situations where that *may* make sense (though I can't think of any), but I think it is callous, and cruel, to boot.
It also implies an assumption that they will be welcomed back into your life, at *their* discretion-- not yours-- and an expectation that you put your life on hold while you wait for them to make up their mind.
Sorry that's happening in your world.
Thank you. I do want to make it clear that I didn't post all this to get sympathy or help in bashing him. I bash him enough in my own head as it is.
I agree that by putting the "just a few weeks" with the "I need a break", just implies that I should wait. I did tell him at that time that I could not make any promises as to how I would feel when he was done with his "break", his response was "I'm not asking you to. I do understand.". I took a huge step the night before by deleting all of his texts, pics and contact info in my phone. I know that if I had the strength to take that big of a step, then I have enough strength to leap forward and leave him behind, permanently!
Yikes! Wasn't bashing him-- lol-- nor did I think you were fishing for sympathy.
Looked like you needed some validation, which in this instance, I was happy to give-- something about a break for a "few weeks" feels-- idk, not quite right.
Unless, like ^ metoo said, above ^, it was mutual.
Geminis, in my experience, aren't fond of confrontation-- but again, my opinion.
How long were you two together? If you mentioned it before, I missed it.
And you have the strength to do any damned thing you want-- that couldn't have been easy.click to expand
Posted by Metoo
eh, those are excuses, and lame ones at that. Sorry but IMO when a guy really Is into you, he will part the red sea to spend time together. Theres always gonna be work and employee issues. Hes just not that into you....that is the translation of "busy" otherwise he wouldn't be texting, he would have picked up the phone.
Im so so sorry to be blunt but I would look at him as a platonic coworker, stop intitiating ANY contact and speak WORK only and get real buy with your work and social life and date someone else who can find balance and make you a priority. "Busy" is ridiculous.
Posted by Scorpio72
Well he text last night saying how much he missed me and explaining how busy he has been with work and what's been going down with one of his employees that's been causing alot of stress on him. We text about work and said it will be awesome to work with me on a new project I have been given that involves him, said he's missed me and is dying to see me but work and his employee situation is preventing him from spending time with me. I didn't go into what he's done via text because things can get misconstrued in texts, this is stuff that needs to be said face to face. So we shall see...
Posted by Scorpio72
Ok, time out. 1. He is not dating anyone else, I know this for a fact. 2. I also know for a fact that he is THAT busy with work. I do work with him so I do know that we have alot going on here that is requiring 18 hours a day of work for him. He is a project manager for a multimillion dollar construction project. All the budgeting and construction falls on his shoulders. Plus, he trains daily for triathlon. The situation with his employee is really complication and he has his hands tied on it by upper management.
Posted by P-Angel
That was a different Scorpio ... but, maybe not.
It seems awfully coincidental that both of you have boyfriends with the exact same job, and has offered a job to you, exactly the same.
We'd love to hear your thoughts! If you're not logged in, you can still share your feedback below. Your input helps us improve the experience for everyone. To post your own content or join the conversation, please log in or create an account.