Question about Lucifer

Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
does Satan have any punishing duties or responsibility according to the religions you know? if yes, would he punish us in this life?

I got the feeling that the TV series "Lucifer" is giving wrong information. What I have learned from the old religions is that Satan seduces us, we do sins, we die, and in an unknown point of time there will be a court, then we go to the hell. There we get punished. Also Satan gets punished. Ok, about the last one I'm not sure. Maybe his punishment is to become bored with the hell. probably cause his competency is unsed.

In the TV series Lucifer tends to punish people for their sins. I mean is he a judge? Or has the concept of Satan older roots than in the middle eastern religions?
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Okay, this is what I have been taught:

Satan is here to gather people to go to hell with him. That is his bet with God - that he will take God's beloved man to hell with him. Satan doesn't punish, but he leads people to The Punishment. He will not get bored in hell because hell is a painful place and he will suffer. But he will be happy that he has brought you to suffer with him.
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by DickButt
No he's a sworn enemy of god who has vowed to mislead people into sin as long as the earth is turning, while god says he will continue to forgive them as long as they repent.

Ah, thank you. I get from your response that he has no additional responsibility to punish us.

Not sure if he is an enemy of God. To my information he rebelled, doubted, debated, and got permission for a special task which is misleading.

God gave him the permission or the mission and yet told him he would be put to hell forever. as a result.
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by LillyPetal
Okay, this is what I have been taught:

Satan is here to gather people to go to hell with him. That is his bet with God - that he will take God's beloved man to hell with him. Satan doesn't punish, but he leads people to The Punishment. He will not get bored in hell because hell is a painful place and he will suffer. But he will be happy that he has brought you to suffer with him.



ok, I have never heard of "gathering fellows for the hell". but I like the concept. it makes sense. thank you for the feedback.

I don't know why they try to change the info about Satan.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by LillyPetal
Okay, this is what I have been taught:

Satan is here to gather people to go to hell with him. That is his bet with God - that he will take God's beloved man to hell with him. Satan doesn't punish, but he leads people to The Punishment. He will not get bored in hell because hell is a painful place and he will suffer. But he will be happy that he has brought you to suffer with him.



ok, I have never heard of "gathering fellows for the hell". but I like the concept. it makes sense. thank you for the feedback.

I don't know why they try to change the info about Satan.
click to expand

Pop culture purposes

Also, perhaps if they made it too close to what people actually believe, they may offend some people. Also, creative liberty, I guess.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by DickButt
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by DickButt
No he's a sworn enemy of god who has vowed to mislead people into sin as long as the earth is turning, while god says he will continue to forgive them as long as they repent.

Ah, thank you. I get from your response that he has no additional responsibility to punish us.

Not sure if he is an enemy of God. To my information he rebelled, doubted, debated, and got permission for a special task which is misleading.

God gave him the permission or the mission and yet told him he would be put to hell forever. as a result.
After rebelling and asking for respite till the day of judgement, his hubris led him to where he is now. His hubris cause him to rebel. God hates hubris, in my religion it is said a mustard seeds worth of hubris will cause one to go to hell. So in that interpretation i concluded he's an enemy to God. But you are also right in your reasoning.
click to expand

Can you explain "hubris"?
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by LillyPetal
.... Satan doesn't punish, but he leads people to The Punishment. He will not get bored in hell because hell is a painful place and he will suffer. But he will be happy that he has brought you to suffer with him.



... I don't know why they try to change the info about Satan.
Pop culture purposes

Also, perhaps if they made it too close to what people actually believe, they may offend some people. Also, creative liberty, I guess.

+

Posted by LadyNeptune
God is dead.
click to expand


you see? they say God is dead but are still flirting with the concept of Satan. and change the concept for entertainment goals.

The spider man, or the fantastic four, or Thor&Odin&Loki did not confuse me at all. But with this punishing Lucifer I feel betrayed. I can have peace again if I find a wiki site about nordic mythology. Or Indian whatever.
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by Impulsv
How does it work for the religions that believe in karma

well, which religion is it? I'm still googling.

Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by LillyPetal
.... Satan doesn't punish, but he leads people to The Punishment....

... I don't know why they try to change the info about Satan.

Pop culture purposes

... creative liberty, I guess.
click to expand


With googling "Lucifer karma" I get lots of entries for "Huge Lucifer* - Karma (CD, Album) at Discogs".

It seems "Lucifer" and "Karma" are trendy.

This reminds me of 2 broke girls and the "cronut" craze: half-croissant and half-donut sums up two things together that those people loved. Yeah, this TV Lucifer brings two things in one. Punishment and Seduction.
Profile picture of Ram416
Ram416
@Ram416
9 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4530 · Posts: 12486 · Topics: 56
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by LillyPetal
.... Satan doesn't punish, but he leads people to The Punishment. He will not get bored in hell because hell is a painful place and he will suffer. But he will be happy that he has brought you to suffer with him.



... I don't know why they try to change the info about Satan.
Pop culture purposes

Also, perhaps if they made it too close to what people actually believe, they may offend some people. Also, creative liberty, I guess.

+

Posted by LadyNeptune
God is dead.

you see? they say God is dead but are still flirting with the concept of Satan. and change the concept for entertainment goals.

The spider man, or the fantastic four, or Thor&Odin&Loki did not confuse me at all. But with this punishing Lucifer I feel betrayed. I can have peace again if I find a wiki site about nordic mythology. Or Indian whatever.
click to expand

The TV show is purely for entertainment purposes. It's a reproduction of the graphic novel series, which is much closer to the concept of Lucifer's existence and purpose. Unfortunately because of media hype etc., the TV series completely misses the mark.
Profile picture of Montgomery
Montgomery
@Montgomery
12 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 552 · Posts: 18848 · Topics: 149
Posted by DwellingOnMove
does Satan have any punishing duties or responsibility according to the religions you know? if yes, would he punish us in this life?

I got the feeling that the TV series "Lucifer" is giving wrong information. What I have learned from the old religions is that Satan seduces us, we do sins, we die, and in an unknown point of time there will be a court, then we go to the hell. There we get punished. Also Satan gets punished. Ok, about the last one I'm not sure. Maybe his punishment is to become bored with the hell. probably cause his competency is unsed.

In the TV series Lucifer tends to punish people for their sins. I mean is he a judge? Or has the concept of Satan older roots than in the middle eastern religions?
No... no punishing duties.

He's the Adversary... not the Judge.

There will be no Hell, when it's all over, nor will there be

any death-- both are thrown into the lake of fire.



'... and the Devil, who is leading them astray, was cast into

the lake of fire and brimstone, where [are] the beast and the

false prophet, and they shall be tormented day and night --

to the ages of the ages.

... and the death and the hades were cast to the lake of the fire --

this [is] the second death... '

-Rev. 20:10,14, 15

YLT







Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by lady_chatterley
... our own thoughts or ideas that leads us astray.

... devil simply means selfishness, turning oneself away from God, the evil you might call it.

...

I guess I understand your concept better. Also because I can bring "the punishing" into the equation. So Lucifer (~= selfishness) misleads me, and once I realize what a mistake I did, it (the realisation or Lucifer) makes me blame/hate/harm myself for my sin/flaws/imperfection. So I get punished.

I can understand it as long as external events are excluded. Only my own mind is involved. This is why believing in a forgiving God is part of the belief. Doubting it is losing twice to Satan.

PS: this seems to work but not sure if this comes form any holy books.
Profile picture of CancerOnTheCusp
GFY
@CancerOnTheCusp
12 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 434 · Posts: 8313 · Topics: 311
To OP.

Lucifer is a cute TV show with an interesting twist.

Satan in the Jewish tradition is not necessarily a physical being, but a state where man bends to evil inclinations. The most notable area in the Old Testament where Satan is an actual being is in Job, where God and "the adversary" essentially bet that Job's piety is only because things are going great for him.

I'll let you look up the details--its an interesting story.

Non-canonical sources state that when God revealed his plan, Lucifer refused to bow to man who was created in the image of God (the sin of pride, which is considered the kernel of all other sins).

Then the war in Heaven, etc..

There isn't a guy with a van dyke beard and a pitchfork waiting to roast someone over a spit for jaywalking.

It boils down to the concept of "free will". One's actions or lack thereof that result in denying God, or violation of the Golden Rule, are a result of pride. This results in "the absence of God", through denial.

In fact, Hell can be described as the absence of God.

We punish ourselves. If Satan does act, it is to whisper to man or woman to give into their baser instincts, and it is their decisions that plot the course. The punishments are self-fulfilling prophecies as such, IMHO.

To use media (as you have in your OP), think of it as Marley forging his spiritual chains in "A Christmas Carol", or the initial fate of Annie Collins in "What Dreams May Come".
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by CancerOnTheCusp
...

To use media (as you have in your OP), think of it as Marley forging his spiritual chains in "A Christmas Carol", or the initial fate of Annie Collins in "What Dreams May Come".



oh, I like the Job's story. Especially the part where people say Job is getting punished cause he have done wrong.

But back to the media and pop culture. Actually I don't know why I am so mad at this picturing of Lucifer. Maybe I am a bigot? It was easier for me back then to watch Al Pacino's "The Devil's Advocate".

Maybe I have Asperger regarding spirituality.
Profile picture of CancerOnTheCusp
GFY
@CancerOnTheCusp
12 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 434 · Posts: 8313 · Topics: 311
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by CancerOnTheCusp
...

To use media (as you have in your OP), think of it as Marley forging his spiritual chains in "A Christmas Carol", or the initial fate of Annie Collins in "What Dreams May Come".



oh, I like the Job's story. Especially the part where people say Job is getting punished cause he have done wrong.

But back to the media and pop culture. Actually I don't know why I am so mad at this picturing of Lucifer. Maybe I am a bigot? It was easier for me back then to watch Al Pacino's "The Devil's Advocate".

Maybe I have Asperger regarding spirituality.
click to expand

It's just television. Be entertained, but I certainly wouldn't build a theology around it, LOL.

The interesting part of "The Devil's Advocate" is the interaction after things come to a head when Kevin and Satan are talking. Kevin stating that the abandonment of his wife was "you made me do it". That's when Satan points out that he didn't make Kevin do anything, it was Kevin's vanity (pride) that led him to do what he did.

"Free will, its a bitch".
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
The German wiki for Lucifer has a text which I cannot see in the English version.

"Similar figures

The scheme of stealing fire from Gods, rebeling against them, falling into disgrace with them, and/or getting banned/exiled from their realm exists in several religions. Accordingly, Lucifer is sometimes associated with The deity Loki of the Nordic mythology or Prometheus of Greek mythology."
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
I actually have some respect for Satanist beliefs. I've found that lot of what I know (which isn't much) is based in the Old Testament stories.

Satan's role, as in the Garden, is to tempt us not to sin in the traditional sense (sex, gluttony, pride, etc) but to introduce us to knowledge that we have "no business" knowing. The knowledge of God, of how to give life, how to manipulate matter. To have power over our own mortality, and how to become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

This is how I interpret the story of the Garden.
Profile picture of VenusAquarius
"So I can show off my gold chain, gold ring. Roll through the hood on them gold thangs"
@VenusAquarius
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4341 · Posts: 13269 · Topics: 69
Posted by DwellingOnMove
does Satan have any punishing duties or responsibility according to the religions you know? if yes, would he punish us in this life?

I got the feeling that the TV series "Lucifer" is giving wrong information. What I have learned from the old religions is that Satan seduces us, we do sins, we die, and in an unknown point of time there will be a court, then we go to the hell. There we get punished. Also Satan gets punished. Ok, about the last one I'm not sure. Maybe his punishment is to become bored with the hell. probably cause his competency is unsed.

In the TV series Lucifer tends to punish people for their sins. I mean is he a judge? Or has the concept of Satan older roots than in the middle eastern religions?
The answers are here: http://www.bibleinfo.com/en/topics/satan

I don't like typing alot... so, I look for webpages that coincide with what I know.
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by sultrykitty
... introduce us to knowledge ... become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

...

So first he got his own punishment plan, then he asked God for a favor?

I know what you are saying by "knowledge". In this thread we did not talk about "light bringer". Which is actually the translation of Lucifer. We did not talk about the morning star (or the tract/behavior of Venus). But I sense your post goes to the same path. kind of.
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by sultrykitty
...

Satan's role, as in the Garden, is to tempt us not to sin in the traditional sense (sex, gluttony, pride, etc) but to introduce us to knowledge that we have "no business" knowing. The knowledge of God, of how to give life, how to manipulate matter. To have power over our own mortality, and how to become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

...

I think the devil made us see we have "free will" and if we use it, we can achieve a lot. So there was a basic knowledge. And then the tsunami of everything else. So the science.

But the story does not end at that point. We started to have pain cause we can feel the the pain of our fellow humans whenever we violate their rights. This is why the story also tells how to deal with the results of the free will. Like ask God/fellow to forgive you, have faith that they forgive you and push on the RESET button.
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by sultrykitty
... introduce us to knowledge ... become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

...

So first he got his own punishment plan, then he asked God for a favor?

I know what you are saying by "knowledge". In this thread we did not talk about "light bringer". Which is actually the translation of Lucifer. We did not talk about the morning star (or the tract/behavior of Venus). But I sense your post goes to the same path. kind of.
click to expand

Lucifer was punished, but they have a "balancing" kind of relationship. They work together as adversaries. It's all part of the story, part of the plan. You find it a lot in Jewish writings, and also in the New Testament, where Jesus plays the role of advocate in the courtroom, against the prosecutor ( satan) and God (judge).

Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by Montgomery
Posted by DwellingOnMove
does Satan have any punishing duties or responsibility according to the religions you know? if yes, would he punish us in this life?

I got the feeling that the TV series "Lucifer" is giving wrong information. What I have learned from the old religions is that Satan seduces us, we do sins, we die, and in an unknown point of time there will be a court, then we go to the hell. There we get punished. Also Satan gets punished. Ok, about the last one I'm not sure. Maybe his punishment is to become bored with the hell. probably cause his competency is unsed.

In the TV series Lucifer tends to punish people for their sins. I mean is he a judge? Or has the concept of Satan older roots than in the middle eastern religions?
No... no punishing duties.

He's the Adversary... not the Judge.

There will be no Hell, when it's all over, nor will there be

any death-- both are thrown into the lake of fire.



'... and the Devil, who is leading them astray, was cast into

the lake of fire and brimstone, where [are] the beast and the

false prophet, and they shall be tormented day and night --

to the ages of the ages.

... and the death and the hades were cast to the lake of the fire --

this [is] the second death... '

-Rev. 20:10,14, 15

YLT









click to expand

YESSSS. 🙂



Profile picture of Ram416
Ram416
@Ram416
9 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4530 · Posts: 12486 · Topics: 56
Posted by sultrykitty
I actually have some respect for Satanist beliefs. I've found that lot of what I know (which isn't much) is based in the Old Testament stories.

Satan's role, as in the Garden, is to tempt us not to sin in the traditional sense (sex, gluttony, pride, etc) but to introduce us to knowledge that we have "no business" knowing. The knowledge of God, of how to give life, how to manipulate matter. To have power over our own mortality, and how to become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

This is how I interpret the story of the Garden.
I want to pick your brain.

What do you know of Christian Gnosticism?

15 years in, I'm still exploring that aspect of Christianity. I am aware of the Gnostic Gospels but that's about it.
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
I actually have some respect for Satanist beliefs. I've found that lot of what I know (which isn't much) is based in the Old Testament stories.

Satan's role, as in the Garden, is to tempt us not to sin in the traditional sense (sex, gluttony, pride, etc) but to introduce us to knowledge that we have "no business" knowing. The knowledge of God, of how to give life, how to manipulate matter. To have power over our own mortality, and how to become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

This is how I interpret the story of the Garden.
I want to pick your brain.

What do you know of Christian Gnosticism?

15 years in, I'm still exploring that aspect of Christianity. I am aware of the Gnostic Gospels but that's about it.
click to expand



Not a ton, I debated a little with a Gnostic (an ex-Muslim) and it was very interesting. I know more than some buy can't speak with any authority. All I can do is apply apologetics to their arguments.
Profile picture of Ram416
Ram416
@Ram416
9 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4530 · Posts: 12486 · Topics: 56
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
I actually have some respect for Satanist beliefs. I've found that lot of what I know (which isn't much) is based in the Old Testament stories.

Satan's role, as in the Garden, is to tempt us not to sin in the traditional sense (sex, gluttony, pride, etc) but to introduce us to knowledge that we have "no business" knowing. The knowledge of God, of how to give life, how to manipulate matter. To have power over our own mortality, and how to become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

This is how I interpret the story of the Garden.
I want to pick your brain.

What do you know of Christian Gnosticism?

15 years in, I'm still exploring that aspect of Christianity. I am aware of the Gnostic Gospels but that's about it.


Not a ton, I debated a little with a Gnostic (an ex-Muslim) and it was very interesting. I know more than some buy can't speak with any authority. All I can do is apply apologetics to their arguments.

click to expand

Any references you could recommend? (Apart from the Gospels.)
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
I actually have some respect for Satanist beliefs. I've found that lot of what I know (which isn't much) is based in the Old Testament stories.

Satan's role, as in the Garden, is to tempt us not to sin in the traditional sense (sex, gluttony, pride, etc) but to introduce us to knowledge that we have "no business" knowing. The knowledge of God, of how to give life, how to manipulate matter. To have power over our own mortality, and how to become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

This is how I interpret the story of the Garden.
I want to pick your brain.

What do you know of Christian Gnosticism?

15 years in, I'm still exploring that aspect of Christianity. I am aware of the Gnostic Gospels but that's about it.


Not a ton, I debated a little with a Gnostic (an ex-Muslim) and it was very interesting. I know more than some buy can't speak with any authority. All I can do is apply apologetics to their arguments.


Any references you could recommend? (Apart from the Gospels.)
click to expand



For Gnostic teachings or apologetics?
Profile picture of Ram416
Ram416
@Ram416
9 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4530 · Posts: 12486 · Topics: 56
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
I actually have some respect for Satanist beliefs. I've found that lot of what I know (which isn't much) is based in the Old Testament stories.

Satan's role, as in the Garden, is to tempt us not to sin in the traditional sense (sex, gluttony, pride, etc) but to introduce us to knowledge that we have "no business" knowing. The knowledge of God, of how to give life, how to manipulate matter. To have power over our own mortality, and how to become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

This is how I interpret the story of the Garden.
I want to pick your brain.

What do you know of Christian Gnosticism?

15 years in, I'm still exploring that aspect of Christianity. I am aware of the Gnostic Gospels but that's about it.


Not a ton, I debated a little with a Gnostic (an ex-Muslim) and it was very interesting. I know more than some buy can't speak with any authority. All I can do is apply apologetics to their arguments.


Any references you could recommend? (Apart from the Gospels.)


For Gnostic teachings or apologetics?

click to expand

Both or either.
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
Posted by Ram416
Posted by sultrykitty
I actually have some respect for Satanist beliefs. I've found that lot of what I know (which isn't much) is based in the Old Testament stories.

Satan's role, as in the Garden, is to tempt us not to sin in the traditional sense (sex, gluttony, pride, etc) but to introduce us to knowledge that we have "no business" knowing. The knowledge of God, of how to give life, how to manipulate matter. To have power over our own mortality, and how to become independent from God, as gods to ourselves.

By that rebellion, which is what cast Lucifer out of Heaven, we have purposely distanced ourselves from God, and that is how we end (or exist after death). This is how Lucifer gets his "revenge" for being cast out and less favored.

This is how I interpret the story of the Garden.
I want to pick your brain.

What do you know of Christian Gnosticism?

15 years in, I'm still exploring that aspect of Christianity. I am aware of the Gnostic Gospels but that's about it.


Not a ton, I debated a little with a Gnostic (an ex-Muslim) and it was very interesting. I know more than some buy can't speak with any authority. All I can do is apply apologetics to their arguments.


Any references you could recommend? (Apart from the Gospels.)


For Gnostic teachings or apologetics?


Both or either.
click to expand



I'm on my desktop now - that's where all my old bookmarks are. I'll see what I can dig up. 🙂
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
I was actually trying to find the debate/discussions I had with the Gnostic guy but it's been so long and the forum is no longer in my bookmarks, nor are any of the sites I used to use all the time. I found the forum (I posted in 2007) but I can't find that discussion. I usually post links so thought there would be something



😢

But in searching, I found this. I used to use this a lot.

http://www.earlychristianwritings.com
Profile picture of Ram416
Ram416
@Ram416
9 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4530 · Posts: 12486 · Topics: 56
Posted by sultrykitty
I was actually trying to find the debate/discussions I had with the Gnostic guy but it's been so long and the forum is no longer in my bookmarks, nor are any of the sites I used to use all the time. I found the forum (I posted in 2007) but I can't find that discussion. I usually post links so thought there would be something



😢

But in searching, I found this. I used to use this a lot.

http://www.earlychristianwritings.com


Bookmarked for later reading. Both yours and Impulsv's.

Thank you!
Profile picture of sultrykitty
sultrykitty
@sultrykitty
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 6172 · Topics: 7
Interesting article:

https://phys.org/news/2006-08-devil-prince-darkness-misunderstood-ucla.html

"A strict reading of the Bible shows Satan to be less like Darth Vader and more and more like an overzealous prosecutor," said Kelly, a UCLA professor emeritus of English and the former director of the university's Center for Medieval and Renaissance Studies. "He's not so much the proud and angry figure who turns away from God as [he is] a Joseph McCarthy or J. Edgar Hoover. Satan's basic intention is to uncover wrongdoing and treachery, however overzealous and unscrupulous the means. But he's still part of God's administration."
Profile picture of bricklemark
bricklemark
@bricklemark
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 76 · Posts: 6210 · Topics: 230
Posted by DwellingOnMove
The German wiki for Lucifer has a text which I cannot see in the English version.

"Similar figures

The scheme of stealing fire from Gods, rebeling against them, falling into disgrace with them, and/or getting banned/exiled from their realm exists in several religions. Accordingly, Lucifer is sometimes associated with The deity Loki of the Nordic mythology or Prometheus of Greek mythology."
Stealing fire is a metaphor for reproduction, your kids growing up and learning about sexuality, getting agressive, so you have to kick them out.
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by bricklemark
Posted by DwellingOnMove
The German wiki for Lucifer has a text which I cannot see in the English version.

"Similar figures

The scheme of stealing fire from Gods, rebeling against them, falling into disgrace with them, and/or getting banned/exiled from their realm exists in several religions. Accordingly, Lucifer is sometimes associated with The deity Loki of the Nordic mythology or Prometheus of Greek mythology."
Stealing fire is a metaphor for reproduction, your kids growing up and learning about sexuality, getting agressive, so you have to kick them out.
click to expand


Thank you for the interpretation. that sounds sound.

and this moving out is the beginning of the catastrophe which is the dating life. lol

they say God had to give Adam's children angels for pairing. to avoid incest. we see even half angel in our family tree could helps us only little to be innocent. we bad. lol
Profile picture of DwellingOnMove
DwellingOnMove
@DwellingOnMove
16 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 305 · Posts: 14219 · Topics: 239
Posted by sultrykitty
Interesting article:

https://phys.org/news/2006-08-devil-prince-darkness-misunderstood-ucla.html

"... overzealous prosecutor," ... uncover wrongdoing and treachery, however overzealous and unscrupulous the means. But he's still part of God's administration."

I watched the series in little peaces and I found this is what the series say. Satan was just doing his job. It is people who have wishes. He just asks them. well, he could keep it low key.

complicated administration. and motivations.
Profile picture of bricklemark
bricklemark
@bricklemark
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 76 · Posts: 6210 · Topics: 230
Posted by DwellingOnMove
Posted by bricklemark
Posted by DwellingOnMove
The German wiki for Lucifer has a text which I cannot see in the English version.

"Similar figures

The scheme of stealing fire from Gods, rebeling against them, falling into disgrace with them, and/or getting banned/exiled from their realm exists in several religions. Accordingly, Lucifer is sometimes associated with The deity Loki of the Nordic mythology or Prometheus of Greek mythology."
Stealing fire is a metaphor for reproduction, your kids growing up and learning about sexuality, getting agressive, so you have to kick them out.

Thank you for the interpretation. that sounds sound.

and this moving out is the beginning of the catastrophe which is the dating life. lol

they say God had to give Adam's children angels for pairing. to avoid incest. we see even half angel in our family tree could helps us only little to be innocent. we bad. lol
click to expand

Dating life, and also labor. It says man will have to toil, or work the land or smth.

Never heard of the angels for pairing...jews are them maybe
Profile picture of Lunar
Lunar
@Lunar
8 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 3 · Topics: 0
First of all GOD & SATAN are not an individual entity/person/soul/spirit

What religions mean by the terms God/Satan is the ying yang energy- the balance of these two positive and negative energies.

How we act on a day to day basis either creates God energy or Satan energy as we are all born knowing what is right or wrong. Life is that constant battle of going either way and succumbing to our selfish needs and wants or acting from the heart with compassion. We are in control of our own actions and by following religious belief's that there is a higher force that can control our actions, we sadly regret to own how we act and who we are. .. God energy is the essence of Life...The universe and every single thing in it . God is the perfect balance both negative and positive.