Meeting your sperm donor?

This topic was created in the Relationships forum by Astrobyn on Wednesday, February 10, 2021 and has 68 replies.
You are on page out of 2 | Reverse Order
Looking for pros vs cons, or general opinions about letting my almost 4-year-old meet up with the father that abandoned her at 3 days old.

Long story short, having contact with me interfered with his relationship (he choose after the fact), he didn’t want the responsibility of being a father to her, and then he moved 5 hours away.

I initially proposed to him, they would meet when she was 3, and continue every six months unless she requested it to stop. Which he was opened to, we made plans last year, but so did covid and it never happened.

I have no illusions about them having a relationship, he is open to meeting but again not the responsibility of keeping up an actual relationship.

I see this as giving her the opportunity to see him for herself rather than fantasying some ideal of him.

I still feel torn about making the best decision for her, so I'm taking all opinions into considerations.

Nope supervised zoom calls only
Posted by Fishface

After the initial meeting, will he continue to meet with her or is it just a relationship he chooses to have whenever he wants it?

When we discussed it, the meetings would continue every 6 months. The purpose was for her benefit to know him.

I never really saw it as being in his benefit, as this was something I choose and I control. I don't really know why he's motivated to agree to this.
Posted by Lunamara Nope supervised zoom calls only

I'm am less open to this idea, because I don't want her to have the impression that this an option, and she can have access to him the same way she does Grandma and Grandpa.
Aint meet my pops til I was 17. And it was bitter af in the beginning. I wasnt angry or mad just extremely disappointed I guess because we favored alot and the way we met. So many reasons why it was just difficult for me but now we are somewhat close. Dont even wanna go into detail but I will say I like what our relationship evolved into. We are both pretty distant ppl so we understand or at least accept that we wont hear from each other much. And I think he accepeted that he has to do alot more if he wants me to reach out. All in all, its love there. Real love. I can say that. Just two stubborn ppl who rather be distant with each other than make a real effort. I guees to protect our own feelings


BUT I say that to say this. Let them have a relationship. But the minute he starts making broken ass promises or does this once in a while shit, get on his ass. And if you have to, keep him at a distance until he can be consistent. You dont want your child wondering why daddy comes and goes. Thats just mt personal opinion. Im definitely in my sons life daily. And i cant stand dudes who dont step up. But protect your child first and foremost. And Dont let him start making excuses and doing disappearing acts. I can go on and on bur im sure you understand what im tryna say
I think it should be her choice to make when she is ready to. It kinda feels like your forcing him to be part of her life when he does not really want to be. Its a tough one.
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Queenofthepheasantfairies

I think it should be her choice to make when she is ready to. It kinda feels like your forcing him to be part of her life when he does not really want to be. Its a tough one.


Precisely why I’ve let it be up to her. I explained that he hasn’t mentioned wanting to meet her ever but that if she ever feels like she needs to meet him I will help make it happen.

But so far she is completely indifferent.
click to expand
Yeah I think that's the best way to do it. Let the child make up their own mind. I think by forcing the father who clearly wants nothing to do with the child, will cause far more damage to everyone involved. 4 is very young to let them make up their mind and children that young won't really have much of an opinion other than questions maybe, which you can easily just say they live far away. When the child is at a age when they decide to reach out it can be addressed further.
Also the mere fact that the term "sperms donor" was used means she doesn't even view him as the father to begin with. Let sleeping dogs lie i say.
This is my experience as a granddaughter of the sperm donar and the sister in law of the sperm donar.

I never knew my real grandfather. Neither did my mother. The man I knew as my grandfather legally adopted her when she was like 2 yrs old and so her birth records were sealed. My mom didn't even know her real father's name until she was in her 60s(she knew her dad adopter her but my grandmother refused to talk about her real father until then). Because I work on our family tree my mom asked if I could find her real dad now that we knew his name. It wasn't easy. My grandmother by this time was in her 80s/90s and she gave me what she could remember. I am still not able to get my moms real birth certificate because my grandmother is still alive(at 101 yrs old) however after years of trying I feel like I finally tracked the man down from the info I had only to find out he was dead and died like in the 1980s or early 90s and he lived like 30 mins away from us when he died. All my mom wanted was to "know" him. It took my grandma 60 yrs to just tell her his name. It's sooo fucked up and as a granddaughter it impacted me as well.

My niece and nephews father basically abandoned them when they were young. After my sister divorced him right after my niece was born he moved away to a different state and then left the country where he met a new woman who had a kid, married her and raised her kid as his own. My niece referred to him as the sperm donar because eventually my sister met the man who is still raising them and who they call dad even tho he left my sister. They are teenagers now. However, my sister almost went down the path of my grandmother even went as far as changing their last names to her maden name legally so they no longer have his last name which they were legally born with. His family never took interest in them but eventually my sister made an effort and contacted his family and him in order to let them know him. My niece is still interested in the family tree because she wants to know more about her father's side of the family. Unfortunately for them their father ended up dying a few years ago but they did get to meet him again b4 he died and got to know him through Facebook(he had moved to South America). He is originally from South Africa so his family is still there but I don't think the kids talk to them or know their cousins. I met his sister once after my nephew was born she came to America for that but not for my niece and they are only a year apart so my nephew has no recollection of her visit. But they did get to know their father and even tho they hated him for abandoning them I think they were better adjusted to the fact that he is dead now.

So my advice is to let your daughter know of him and meet him if he wants to meet her. But don't make any promises to her. At least let her make that decision as she gets older before he dies and she wishes she had just known him and now never will.
Posted by blackphvse

I'd wait until she was old enough to make the decision herself. He is open to meeting but not the responsibility of maintaining an actual relationship.. he ain't worth the introduction. If he wanted a relationship with her, that's a different story.

This 100%

❤️ you Rob, you’re a good mommy
If he lives 5 hours away and has a new family, the commitment to meet every 6 months (for hours...days?) may feel like a chore, for both of you. Cancelling, awkwardness, jealousy from siblings, tantrums....may create resentment. A young child should not be given the responsibility to decide such things.

Why not a zoom daddy? Chatting every Christmas and birthdays? She may come to see him as a gift donor, lol.

If it goes well for a few years, perhaps meeting irl?
Posted by Hypnotoad

Was he actually a sperm donor or were you in a relationship where there was the intention that he would be her father and then he went and left when she was born?

No he’s not a legit Sperm donor, I reframed from calling him a deadbeat since the state takes his money. We knew each other for a while through mutual friends, dated for a few months. The day he told me someone else came back into his life and he was going to peruse that, I told him I was pregnant. He told me to get an abortion, I told him I don’t do that.

She was born he spent 3 days seeing her, told me he was glad I didn’t kill her. Acted like he was totally in love with her and was all concerned about what vaccines she was going to get. Then he was distant for a while, said he was out of town dealing with work. Then he got some paperwork the Attorney General, and told me if I filled for Child Support he wouldn’t have anything to do her.


I know she’s young but she’s always talked about him, when I’ve tried to brush it off and not make a big deal about it, she pushes harder about it.

The only reason I asked him, is because I she’s been talking a lot about him lately and we already had a trip planned to be in a meeting place.

My fear was that she would idealize him or have this fantasy about him, and I didn’t want that to happen and I wanted her to empowered with all the knowledge and information as she grows into understanding this.

But I am second guessing myself a year later, she does have a Pisces Moon, and it is like she lives in a dual world of reality and imagination.
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by Hypnotoad

Was he actually a sperm donor or were you in a relationship where there was the intention that he would be her father and then he went and left when she was born?

No he’s not a legit Sperm donor, I reframed from calling him a deadbeat since the state takes his money. We knew each other for a while through mutual friends, dated for a few months. The day he told me someone else came back into his life and he was going to peruse that, I told him I was pregnant. He told me to get an abortion, I told him I don’t do that.

She was born he spent 3 days seeing her, told me he was glad I didn’t kill her. Acted like he was totally in love with her and was all concerned about what vaccines she was going to get. Then he was distant for a while, said he was out of town dealing with work. Then he got some paperwork the Attorney General, and told me if I filled for Child Support he wouldn’t have anything to do her.
click to expand

Dude that last part has me seething

He doesn’t deserve to know her tbh

I applaud you for trying. I know you’re doing it for her, but it doesn’t sound like he is capable of giving her what she is missing or thinks she is missing
I don’t think any parent should be kept from a child.

Parents using kids as some sort of leverage just hurt the kids in the end.

If the guy is a decent person, no addictions or bad child influence type, then the arrangement is a good thing.

As she gets older, she can decide if she wants to continue the relationship.

It will make him face reality and he could also start having a more active role in her life.
I’m not the best at giving advice because I let my heart lead and my head worry about it later.

I think that every child should know who their parents are and have the chance to develop a relationship or decide they don’t want to, like you said....you’re giving her the opportunity for that to happen.

Speaking as a woman - from a divorced family, my mother never kept us from our dad even when she remarried. She always encouraged our phone calls, summer plans, vacations etc and never stood in his way of being with us. After my dad finally got through his alcoholism through therapy and his home was finally ready for us, they split custody (school year with mom, summer and holidays with dad).

Children need both parents and if you have an option to have him in her life and the interactions are healthy, then I would encourage it.

It’s the most selfless thing you can do for her and I think you’re a gem 💎 for wanting to ensure she has this option ❤️
Posted by saggurl88

I don’t think any parent should be kept from a child.

Parents using kids as some sort of leverage just hurt the kids in the end.

If the guy is a decent person, no addictions or bad child influence type, then the arrangement is a good thing.

As she gets older, she can decide if she wants to continue the relationship.

It will make him face reality and he could also start having a more active role in her life.


Yes 🙌🏼! Perfectly said
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by Hypnotoad

Was he actually a sperm donor or were you in a relationship where there was the intention that he would be her father and then he went and left when she was born?

No he’s not a legit Sperm donor, I reframed from calling him a deadbeat since the state takes his money. We knew each other for a while through mutual friends, dated for a few months. The day he told me someone else came back into his life and he was going to peruse that, I told him I was pregnant. He told me to get an abortion, I told him I don’t do that.

She was born he spent 3 days seeing her, told me he was glad I didn’t kill her. Acted like he was totally in love with her and was all concerned about what vaccines she was going to get. Then he was distant for a while, said he was out of town dealing with work. Then he got some paperwork the Attorney General, and told me if I filled for Child Support he wouldn’t have anything to do her.
click to expand
Whoa 😳....I should have read this first.

This changes things a bit.
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by saggurl88

I don’t think any parent should be kept from a child.

Parents using kids as some sort of leverage just hurt the kids in the end.

If the guy is a decent person, no addictions or bad child influence type, then the arrangement is a good thing.

As she gets older, she can decide if she wants to continue the relationship.

It will make him face reality and he could also start having a more active role in her life.


My life would have been 10x easier if I had been kept from knowing my dad.

Giving life to something doesn’t automatically mean you are a parent or worth knowing.
click to expand
Which is why I mentioned if he was a “decent person” with no major issues.

Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Romzz

I’m not the best at giving advice because I let my heart lead and my head worry about it later.

I think that every child should know who their parents are and have the chance to develop a relationship or decide they don’t want to, like you said....you’re giving her the opportunity for that to happen.

Speaking as a woman - from a divorced family, my mother never kept us from our dad even when she remarried. She always encouraged our phone calls, summer plans, vacations etc and never stood in his way of being with us. After my dad finally got through his alcoholism through therapy and his home was finally ready for us, they split custody (school year with mom, summer and holidays with dad).

Children need both parents and if you have an option to have him in her life and the interactions are healthy, then I would encourage it.

It’s the most selfless thing you can do for her and I think you’re a gem 💎 for wanting to ensure she has this option ❤️


Children don’t “need” both bio parents. It’s ideal but it’s not necessary for happiness.

Do they need adults that actually give a shit about their existence and in there every day showing commitment and support to them? Absolutely and as many as possible and of others genders too.

That’s how they learn love.

Not by some wishy washy spineless dude that probably only wants to get his money’s worth.
click to expand
Children love unconditionally, no matter what their parents have done to them. Even if they were bad

A parent purposely keeping their child from the father and a child not understanding why, is a recipe for disaster.

Your own child could turn on you later in life even though you thought you were protecting them.

Children need to make their own choices just as much as adults do. Especially if he is a healthy man who is willing to be in her life.
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Romzz

I’m not the best at giving advice because I let my heart lead and my head worry about it later.

I think that every child should know who their parents are and have the chance to develop a relationship or decide they don’t want to, like you said....you’re giving her the opportunity for that to happen.

Speaking as a woman - from a divorced family, my mother never kept us from our dad even when she remarried. She always encouraged our phone calls, summer plans, vacations etc and never stood in his way of being with us. After my dad finally got through his alcoholism through therapy and his home was finally ready for us, they split custody (school year with mom, summer and holidays with dad).

Children need both parents and if you have an option to have him in her life and the interactions are healthy, then I would encourage it.

It’s the most selfless thing you can do for her and I think you’re a gem 💎 for wanting to ensure she has this option ❤️


Children don’t “need” both bio parents. It’s ideal but it’s not necessary for happiness.

Do they need adults that actually give a shit about their existence and in there every day showing commitment and support to them? Absolutely and as many as possible and of others genders too.

That’s how they learn love.

Not by some wishy washy spineless dude that probably only wants to get his money’s worth.
click to expand
Everyone’s going to have a different opinion. Do you have children?

Of course it’s ideal. That’s why theirs countless studies done on how children interact with both parents and how it influences them and effects their self confidence etc.

Anyway lol I didn’t know about the latter half of the story until after so chill 😆
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by saggurl88
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by saggurl88

I don’t think any parent should be kept from a child.

Parents using kids as some sort of leverage just hurt the kids in the end.

If the guy is a decent person, no addictions or bad child influence type, then the arrangement is a good thing.

As she gets older, she can decide if she wants to continue the relationship.

It will make him face reality and he could also start having a more active role in her life.


My life would have been 10x easier if I had been kept from knowing my dad.

Giving life to something doesn’t automatically mean you are a parent or worth knowing.


Which is why I mentioned if he was a “decent person” with no major issues.

I guess our definitions of “decent” are different.

Abandoning a child because it’s not convenient for you doesn’t scream decent.
click to expand
So she should just be kept from him then. Now doesn’t count? 🤣🤣🤣

Fucking ridiculous.

People live to be 100 nowadays, 3 years of a child’s life is nothing compared to a lifetime of having a parent finally show up in a kids childhood.
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by saggurl88
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Romzz

I’m not the best at giving advice because I let my heart lead and my head worry about it later.

I think that every child should know who their parents are and have the chance to develop a relationship or decide they don’t want to, like you said....you’re giving her the opportunity for that to happen.

Speaking as a woman - from a divorced family, my mother never kept us from our dad even when she remarried. She always encouraged our phone calls, summer plans, vacations etc and never stood in his way of being with us. After my dad finally got through his alcoholism through therapy and his home was finally ready for us, they split custody (school year with mom, summer and holidays with dad).

Children need both parents and if you have an option to have him in her life and the interactions are healthy, then I would encourage it.

It’s the most selfless thing you can do for her and I think you’re a gem 💎 for wanting to ensure she has this option ❤️


Children don’t “need” both bio parents. It’s ideal but it’s not necessary for happiness.

Do they need adults that actually give a shit about their existence and in there every day showing commitment and support to them? Absolutely and as many as possible and of others genders too.

That’s how they learn love.

Not by some wishy washy spineless dude that probably only wants to get his money’s worth.


Children love unconditionally, no matter what their parents have done to them. Even if they were bad

A parent purposely keeping their child from the father and a child not understanding why, is a recipe for disaster.

Your own child could turn on you later in life even though you thought you were protecting them.

Children need to make their own choices just as much as adults do. Especially if he is a healthy man who is willing to be in her life.


Not true for that first bit. That’s your experience maybe.

And any child would distance themselves from a parent that doesn’t have open communication and honesty with them.

But the child is four. There is obviously something there which is why I asked where that was coming from and if she has talked to her kid about it but parenting can be a balance of knowing when to guide and when to listen.

There is some amount of protection you have to do as a parent but slowly over time you have to let go and allow your kid to make their own decisions, but at this point if you let your 4 year old meet someone and then that person checks out again, you are setting them up for a heart break they can’t process as easily as when they are older and have more information and more self assurance.

Again... he will show what he wants. He knows how to contact her and he knows what he would need to do to be in the girls life and he’s not choosing her.

Forcing a kid to put themselves into an emotionally vulnerable situation based on unreciprocated interest to assuage your own guilt doesn’t work.

If you continually touch on the subject over time and he continuously shows up then I could see that being a reasonable scenario for reconciliation but I don’t see they from what has been shared here.
click to expand
You can’t possibly know what this man is going to do. So all scenarios are ridiculous to assume.

I still stand by what I say and my opinion hasn’t changed.
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by saggurl88

I don’t think any parent should be kept from a child.

Parents using kids as some sort of leverage just hurt the kids in the end.

If the guy is a decent person, no addictions or bad child influence type, then the arrangement is a good thing.

As she gets older, she can decide if she wants to continue the relationship.

It will make him face reality and he could also start having a more active role in her life.


My life would have been 10x easier if I had been kept from knowing my dad.

Giving life to something doesn’t automatically mean you are a parent or worth knowing.
click to expand
No, but if you read my post you will see what happens when you are kept from knowing them. I've seen all sides of this story. It's not perfect either way but at least you had a chance to know your parent. You aren't left with questions that can't and never will be answered.
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Romzz
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Romzz

I’m not the best at giving advice because I let my heart lead and my head worry about it later.

I think that every child should know who their parents are and have the chance to develop a relationship or decide they don’t want to, like you said....you’re giving her the opportunity for that to happen.

Speaking as a woman - from a divorced family, my mother never kept us from our dad even when she remarried. She always encouraged our phone calls, summer plans, vacations etc and never stood in his way of being with us. After my dad finally got through his alcoholism through therapy and his home was finally ready for us, they split custody (school year with mom, summer and holidays with dad).

Children need both parents and if you have an option to have him in her life and the interactions are healthy, then I would encourage it.

It’s the most selfless thing you can do for her and I think you’re a gem 💎 for wanting to ensure she has this option ❤️


Children don’t “need” both bio parents. It’s ideal but it’s not necessary for happiness.

Do they need adults that actually give a shit about their existence and in there every day showing commitment and support to them? Absolutely and as many as possible and of others genders too.

That’s how they learn love.

Not by some wishy washy spineless dude that probably only wants to get his money’s worth.


Everyone’s going to have a different opinion. Do you have children?

Of course it’s ideal. That’s why theirs countless studies done on how children interact with both parents and how it influences them and effects their self confidence etc.

Anyway lol I didn’t know about the latter half of the story until after so chill 😆


I’m Twinkz. 😐
click to expand



lol 😂.......whelp 🙋🏻‍♀️ hi

I can’t believe I didn’t see that.
Posted by saggurl88
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Romzz

I’m not the best at giving advice because I let my heart lead and my head worry about it later.

I think that every child should know who their parents are and have the chance to develop a relationship or decide they don’t want to, like you said....you’re giving her the opportunity for that to happen.

Speaking as a woman - from a divorced family, my mother never kept us from our dad even when she remarried. She always encouraged our phone calls, summer plans, vacations etc and never stood in his way of being with us. After my dad finally got through his alcoholism through therapy and his home was finally ready for us, they split custody (school year with mom, summer and holidays with dad).

Children need both parents and if you have an option to have him in her life and the interactions are healthy, then I would encourage it.

It’s the most selfless thing you can do for her and I think you’re a gem 💎 for wanting to ensure she has this option ❤️


Children don’t “need” both bio parents. It’s ideal but it’s not necessary for happiness.

Do they need adults that actually give a shit about their existence and in there every day showing commitment and support to them? Absolutely and as many as possible and of others genders too.

That’s how they learn love.

Not by some wishy washy spineless dude that probably only wants to get his money’s worth.


Children love unconditionally, no matter what their parents have done to them. Even if they were bad

A parent purposely keeping their child from the father and a child not understanding why, is a recipe for disaster.

Your own child could turn on you later in life even though you thought you were protecting them.

Children need to make their own choices just as much as adults do. Especially if he is a healthy man who is willing to be in her life.
click to expand

But Rob isn’t purposefully keeping him away from her at all. She’s trying to encourage and help facilitate a relationship when he is making it clear he doesn’t really care. He isn’t that willing. He’s “open to meeting her” meaning he doesn’t really give a shit but he’d try it out

That’s more harmful to a child IMO

She’s important and worthy and deserving of love

I’ve seen the other side where a woman keeps a child from their dad and it’s really sad...that’s not what’s happening here

At least you got plenty of different opinions to take into consideration

Posted by brianafay
Posted by saggurl88
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Romzz

I’m not the best at giving advice because I let my heart lead and my head worry about it later.

I think that every child should know who their parents are and have the chance to develop a relationship or decide they don’t want to, like you said....you’re giving her the opportunity for that to happen.

Speaking as a woman - from a divorced family, my mother never kept us from our dad even when she remarried. She always encouraged our phone calls, summer plans, vacations etc and never stood in his way of being with us. After my dad finally got through his alcoholism through therapy and his home was finally ready for us, they split custody (school year with mom, summer and holidays with dad).

Children need both parents and if you have an option to have him in her life and the interactions are healthy, then I would encourage it.

It’s the most selfless thing you can do for her and I think you’re a gem 💎 for wanting to ensure she has this option ❤️


Children don’t “need” both bio parents. It’s ideal but it’s not necessary for happiness.

Do they need adults that actually give a shit about their existence and in there every day showing commitment and support to them? Absolutely and as many as possible and of others genders too.

That’s how they learn love.

Not by some wishy washy spineless dude that probably only wants to get his money’s worth.


Children love unconditionally, no matter what their parents have done to them. Even if they were bad

A parent purposely keeping their child from the father and a child not understanding why, is a recipe for disaster.

Your own child could turn on you later in life even though you thought you were protecting them.

Children need to make their own choices just as much as adults do. Especially if he is a healthy man who is willing to be in her life.

But Rob isn’t purposefully keeping him away from her at all. She’s trying to encourage and help facilitate a relationship when he is making it clear he doesn’t really care. He isn’t that willing. He’s “open to meeting her” meaning he doesn’t really give a shit but he’d try it out

That’s more harmful to a child IMO

She’s important and worthy and deserving of love

I’ve seen the other side where a woman keeps a child from their dad and it’s really sad...that’s not what’s happening here
click to expand
Well I still don't get it. He is willing to meet with her, that is what I read. Whether it's twice a year now, or twice a year when the kid is 12 makes a huge difference. That's 9 years lost.

Can she raise the child on her own, of course she can, but I commend her for trying to make sure her daughter knows who her father is.

Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by SeaLion
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by saggurl88

I don’t think any parent should be kept from a child.

Parents using kids as some sort of leverage just hurt the kids in the end.

If the guy is a decent person, no addictions or bad child influence type, then the arrangement is a good thing.

As she gets older, she can decide if she wants to continue the relationship.

It will make him face reality and he could also start having a more active role in her life.


My life would have been 10x easier if I had been kept from knowing my dad.

Giving life to something doesn’t automatically mean you are a parent or worth knowing.


No, but if you read my post you will see what happens when you are kept from knowing them. I've seen all sides of this story. It's not perfect either way but at least you had a chance to know your parent. You aren't left with questions that can't and never will be answered.


Yes but as a four year old you aren’t going to be able to comprehend that emotionally or process.

Waiting until a kid is older makes more sense. It’s not “keeping them away” it’s protecting your child until they are ready to both understand and handle the situation.
click to expand
I agree 4 is to young for her to make that decision for herself but her daughter is already asking about him so it would be better if she met him. Atleast she would "know" who he is. Like I said, don't make any promises like she will see him often, but, yo, this is your dad. My mom doesn't even know what her father looked liked. Neither do I. It's sad.
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Astrobyn

Looking for pros vs cons, or general opinions about letting my almost 4-year-old meet up with the father that abandoned her at 3 days old.

Long story short, having contact with me interfered with his relationship (he choose after the fact), he didn’t want the responsibility of being a father to her, and then he moved 5 hours away.

I initially proposed to him, they would meet when she was 3, and continue every six months unless she requested it to stop. Which he was opened to, we made plans last year, but so did covid and it never happened.

I have no illusions about them having a relationship, he is open to meeting but again not the responsibility of keeping up an actual relationship.

I see this as giving her the opportunity to see him for herself rather than fantasying some ideal of him.

I still feel torn about making the best decision for her, so I'm taking all opinions into considerations.


Hey Dazed wanted me to let you know:

"Fwiw.. at the age of 12, my mother gave me all of the info I needed to contact my biological father. I'm 34 and still haven't reached out to him."
click to expand
Wonder what would've happened if he met his dad when he was 3. 😏
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Astrobyn

Looking for pros vs cons, or general opinions about letting my almost 4-year-old meet up with the father that abandoned her at 3 days old.

Long story short, having contact with me interfered with his relationship (he choose after the fact), he didn’t want the responsibility of being a father to her, and then he moved 5 hours away.

I initially proposed to him, they would meet when she was 3, and continue every six months unless she requested it to stop. Which he was opened to, we made plans last year, but so did covid and it never happened.

I have no illusions about them having a relationship, he is open to meeting but again not the responsibility of keeping up an actual relationship.

I see this as giving her the opportunity to see him for herself rather than fantasying some ideal of him.

I still feel torn about making the best decision for her, so I'm taking all opinions into considerations.


Hey Dazed wanted me to let you know:

"Fwiw.. at the age of 12, my mother gave me all of the info I needed to contact my biological father. I'm 34 and still haven't reached out to him."
click to expand

obviously he didn't take a vow of silence, did he get himself banned?
So you are invested, this is how the conversations is currently going.

Me:

We are supposed to be in _________ the __st of this month. It could be an option to meet somewhere in the early afternoon if you are available.

Him:

I can probably make that happen. Do you think it would be okay for her mentally to meet me but not see me that often?

Me:

Well, I really haven’t given it any more thought beyond, she woke up this morning and said she had a dream about you, you were a superhero and you could fly. And went on about you all day long *eye roll*. Since we had this trip planned, I thought it might be the universe's way of telling me to throw it out there, and if it happens then that’s the plan.

But you do bring up good points, that are worth revisiting now that she’s older and changed. So since you questioned the universe, here are a few questions for you.

Should she never expect to have a relationship with you? (Regardless of logistics.) If yes explain what her expectations should be.

Why would you choose to meet with her?

Him:

I did not question the universe I brought up a valid point that I do not think you considered. I am not saying anything on what should or shouldnt be done just your thoughts on that matter. I did tell you I would meet if the opportunity presented itself.

Me:

why in the world would you think I haven’t considered this?

When I brought this idea up, I specifically asked if you were willing to meet her when she was 3 and continue to meet every six months unless she asked for it to stop. Those were the terms I presented and it took some back and forth, some questions and answers and months for me to be comfortable with it. This was all specifically designed for her benefit.

The age the visits should start and even the amount of time between visits was carefully considered, it’s frequent enough that she has a fresh idea of who you are, but not so frequent that she should feel encouraged to expect more from you.

It is my job to manage her expectations, it was my fear that she would have these fantasies about who you were and idealize some concept of you without having any knowledge and understanding the actual person you are. My goal was to empower her with experience as she grows into her understanding of it all.

Last month she told me that her dad only likes babies, because he only liked her when she was a baby. I will never have the power to fix that, maybe meeting you will help, maybe it will make it worse. I’m honestly doing my best to figure that out. Damage is already inevitable no matter what path is chosen; neither is ok for her mentally, so the way in which you question this just confuses me.

I thought that we were on the same page about this, but it’s made me realize I don’t think I have a good understanding about how you really feel, and what you are willing to give her. And maybe you don’t have a good understanding of where I’m coming from, so I'm trying my best to clearly communicate that.

I get that this is a difficult situation, and there is no part of me that wants to pressure or guilt you into any of this. That would be the worst thing for her, so we can stop right now if that's how you feel.

My goal is to be objective and go over the facts with you. But my questions are still valid, I need to know how to prepare, proceed, and be comfortable that this is right for her.

Should she never expect to have a relationship with you? (Regardless of logistics.) If yes explain what her expectations should be. Here are some options

Meet once

Meet every 6 months (if logistical, otherwise maybe video chat)

Meet every 6 months, and have a 15 min phone call once a month?

Why would you choose to meet with her?

Posted by Arinoaqua

Could we know his sign 🙇🏻‍♀️

sure..

Sun: Sag

Moon: Aqua

Merc: Sag

Venus: Scorpio

Mars: Cap

Posted by Lunamara Nope supervised zoom calls only
Yeah in light of a global pandemic zoom calls are the way to go.
Ultimately make it all about what the kid wants. Start with zoom calls and schedule a set time for him to call each week or whatever the agreed upon amount is. Then see if he follows through or flakes. She needs consistency, not the damaging emotional toll of having her bio dad walk in and out of her life when its convenient for him.

Let her organically ask to see him, when and if she wants.

Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Astrobyn

So you are invested, this is how the conversations is currently going.

Me:

We are supposed to be in _________ the __st of this month. It could be an option to meet somewhere in the early afternoon if you are available.

Him:

I can probably make that happen. Do you think it would be okay for her mentally to meet me but not see me that often?

Me:

Well, I really haven’t given it any more thought beyond, she woke up this morning and said she had a dream about you, you were a superhero and you could fly. And went on about you all day long *eye roll*. Since we had this trip planned, I thought it might be the universe's way of telling me to throw it out there, and if it happens then that’s the plan.

But you do bring up good points, that are worth revisiting now that she’s older and changed. So since you questioned the universe, here are a few questions for you.

Should she never expect to have a relationship with you? (Regardless of logistics.) If yes explain what her expectations should be.

Why would you choose to meet with her?

Him:

I did not question the universe I brought up a valid point that I do not think you considered. I am not saying anything on what should or shouldnt be done just your thoughts on that matter. I did tell you I would meet if the opportunity presented itself.

Me:

why in the world would you think I haven’t considered this?

When I brought this idea up, I specifically asked if you were willing to meet her when she was 3 and continue to meet every six months unless she asked for it to stop. Those were the terms I presented and it took some back and forth, some questions and answers and months for me to be comfortable with it. This was all specifically designed for her benefit.

The age the visits should start and even the amount of time between visits was carefully considered, it’s frequent enough that she has a fresh idea of who you are, but not so frequent that she should feel encouraged to expect more from you.

It is my job to manage her expectations, it was my fear that she would have these fantasies about who you were and idealize some concept of you without having any knowledge and understanding the actual person you are. My goal was to empower her with experience as she grows into her understanding of it all.

Last month she told me that her dad only likes babies, because he only liked her when she was a baby. I will never have the power to fix that, maybe meeting you will help, maybe it will make it worse. I’m honestly doing my best to figure that out. Damage is already inevitable no matter what path is chosen; neither is ok for her mentally, so the way in which you question this just confuses me.

I thought that we were on the same page about this, but it’s made me realize I don’t think I have a good understanding about how you really feel, and what you are willing to give her. And maybe you don’t have a good understanding of where I’m coming from, so I'm trying my best to clearly communicate that.

I get that this is a difficult situation, and there is no part of me that wants to pressure or guilt you into any of this. That would be the worst thing for her, so we can stop right now if that's how you feel.

My goal is to be objective and go over the facts with you. But my questions are still valid, I need to know how to prepare, proceed, and be comfortable that this is right for her.

Should she never expect to have a relationship with you? (Regardless of logistics.) If yes explain what her expectations should be. Here are some options

Meet once

Meet every 6 months (if logistical, otherwise maybe video chat)

Meet every 6 months, and have a 15 min phone call once a month?

Why would you choose to meet with her?


Girl this makes me want to cry so hard because I’ve been here.

But you are putting in the work while he’s passively saying he will meet her but ignoring the rest of your questions. I guess we will have to see again how he responds again but I think the ultimate answer is he’s not willing to put in the work.

Unfortunately its not ideal where he is trying to seek her out as an adult.... and I personally believe that trying to force something that isn’t there only will teach her to invest emotional energy in situations that wont honor her self worth in the long run.

Of course I ran off and she found a father figure in my ex husband who is literally her dad now and she has up until this point never really brought up any lingering questions about her bio dad when I revisit the subject over the years. Not all kids will react the same but it’s quite possible that she won’t be damaged by it.

Plus you never know who will come into her life that actually wants to be there for her.

Ugh. I’m so so sorry you are in this position.

I just want to hug you and your little girl and let you know you’ll both be okay. ❤️

Ultimately the hardest part of parenting is the constant desire to protect and do the best for our kids and it’s a huge balance and knowing a lot of our decisions have a huge impact on another persons trajectory and lifetime wellbeing is an immense responsibility.

Whatever the outcome you will have navigated rough waters for her and done the work to make sure she feels strong and protected and loved.

That’s the best any mother can do. You will get through this no matter what decision you make and think is best.
click to expand

One of the hardest things was to learn how to forgive him for the all of the pain that he has and will cause her.

And it is always challenging, but I can’t teach her to except him as he is, and forgive him with any kind of grace, if I don’t know how to do it myself.

And really that’s the only long term plan I got here, if I’m lucky it might be good enough.

Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by Tomboyyyy
Posted by Astrobyn

So you are invested, this is how the conversations is currently going.

Me:

We are supposed to be in _________ the __st of this month. It could be an option to meet somewhere in the early afternoon if you are available.

Him:

I can probably make that happen. Do you think it would be okay for her mentally to meet me but not see me that often?

Me:

Well, I really haven’t given it any more thought beyond, she woke up this morning and said she had a dream about you, you were a superhero and you could fly. And went on about you all day long *eye roll*. Since we had this trip planned, I thought it might be the universe's way of telling me to throw it out there, and if it happens then that’s the plan.

But you do bring up good points, that are worth revisiting now that she’s older and changed. So since you questioned the universe, here are a few questions for you.

Should she never expect to have a relationship with you? (Regardless of logistics.) If yes explain what her expectations should be.

Why would you choose to meet with her?

Him:

I did not question the universe I brought up a valid point that I do not think you considered. I am not saying anything on what should or shouldnt be done just your thoughts on that matter. I did tell you I would meet if the opportunity presented itself.

Me:

why in the world would you think I haven’t considered this?

When I brought this idea up, I specifically asked if you were willing to meet her when she was 3 and continue to meet every six months unless she asked for it to stop. Those were the terms I presented and it took some back and forth, some questions and answers and months for me to be comfortable with it. This was all specifically designed for her benefit.

The age the visits should start and even the amount of time between visits was carefully considered, it’s frequent enough that she has a fresh idea of who you are, but not so frequent that she should feel encouraged to expect more from you.

It is my job to manage her expectations, it was my fear that she would have these fantasies about who you were and idealize some concept of you without having any knowledge and understanding the actual person you are. My goal was to empower her with experience as she grows into her understanding of it all.

Last month she told me that her dad only likes babies, because he only liked her when she was a baby. I will never have the power to fix that, maybe meeting you will help, maybe it will make it worse. I’m honestly doing my best to figure that out. Damage is already inevitable no matter what path is chosen; neither is ok for her mentally, so the way in which you question this just confuses me.

I thought that we were on the same page about this, but it’s made me realize I don’t think I have a good understanding about how you really feel, and what you are willing to give her. And maybe you don’t have a good understanding of where I’m coming from, so I'm trying my best to clearly communicate that.

I get that this is a difficult situation, and there is no part of me that wants to pressure or guilt you into any of this. That would be the worst thing for her, so we can stop right now if that's how you feel.

My goal is to be objective and go over the facts with you. But my questions are still valid, I need to know how to prepare, proceed, and be comfortable that this is right for her.

Should she never expect to have a relationship with you? (Regardless of logistics.) If yes explain what her expectations should be. Here are some options

Meet once

Meet every 6 months (if logistical, otherwise maybe video chat)

Meet every 6 months, and have a 15 min phone call once a month?

Why would you choose to meet with her?


Girl this makes me want to cry so hard because I’ve been here.

But you are putting in the work while he’s passively saying he will meet her but ignoring the rest of your questions. I guess we will have to see again how he responds again but I think the ultimate answer is he’s not willing to put in the work.

Unfortunately its not ideal where he is trying to seek her out as an adult.... and I personally believe that trying to force something that isn’t there only will teach her to invest emotional energy in situations that wont honor her self worth in the long run.

Of course I ran off and she found a father figure in my ex husband who is literally her dad now and she has up until this point never really brought up any lingering questions about her bio dad when I revisit the subject over the years. Not all kids will react the same but it’s quite possible that she won’t be damaged by it.

Plus you never know who will come into her life that actually wants to be there for her.

Ugh. I’m so so sorry you are in this position.

I just want to hug you and your little girl and let you know you’ll both be okay. ❤️

Ultimately the hardest part of parenting is the constant desire to protect and do the best for our kids and it’s a huge balance and knowing a lot of our decisions have a huge impact on another persons trajectory and lifetime wellbeing is an immense responsibility.

Whatever the outcome you will have navigated rough waters for her and done the work to make sure she feels strong and protected and loved.

That’s the best any mother can do. You will get through this no matter what decision you make and think is best.

One of the hardest things was to learn how to forgive him for the all of the pain that he has and will cause her.

And it is always challenging, but I can’t teach her to except him as he is, and forgive him with any kind of grace, if I don’t know how to do it myself.

And really that’s the only long term plan I got here, if I’m lucky it might be good enough.
click to expand
My dad was in and out of my life, and I'm glad to have known him.

He died when I was about 17, but was barely in my life after my mom died when me and my twin brother was 4.

My brother never met with him and didn't care when he died either. I didn't have much feelings either way, because he was practically a stranger.

But I'm still glad to have known who he was, ask important family history type questions, and stuff like that.

You just have to make the best decision for your family dynamic

You never know what can happen over the years, whether someone lives or dies, shows up or is absent.

She is young enough now, to meet him and if things turn sour later on, she will still have some memory of who he was. This is just the first meet up though, if he ends up being flaky, then you should make decisions about how to proceed.

But I think you are doing a great job of trying to give your daughter some understanding of where she came from.
Am I the only person who thinks it is completely inappropriate for a child to meet her father via zoom?

Gawd. WHAT A TIME TO BE ALIVE
Posted by CoffeeAndCream

Does sperm donor pay to raise the child?


I'm always pro the father

whether he comes in and out of her life is another thing

but having a father figure present is important

The Texas Attorney General takes it away from him he got behind for a few years, and made an effort to get caught up last year. But he framed as it helped his credit to do so.

I tried to be supportive telling him, "I knew you could do it, because you're a perfectly good white man and opportunities were bound to come your way." He never likes my jokes.
Posted by brianafay

Am I the only person who thinks it is completely inappropriate for a child to meet her father via zoom?

Gawd. WHAT A TIME TO BE ALIVE

I get it.
Posted by Astrobyn

Long story short, having contact with me interfered with his relationship (he choose after the fact), he didn’t want the responsibility of being a father to her, and then he moved 5 hours away.

Is he still in this relationship? Or did that end.
Posted by LadyNeptune
Posted by Astrobyn

Long story short, having contact with me interfered with his relationship (he choose after the fact), he didn’t want the responsibility of being a father to her, and then he moved 5 hours away.


Is he still in this relationship? Or did that end.
click to expand

I honestly don't know, I assume he is, they might even be married by this point. I don't try to find out those things. I've made my wishes clear that it would be just him, which he's agreed to.

I would be very uncomfortable with my daughter being around that woman, she played a big part in helping him cultivate some fucked up ideas he had about me and the situation, and has completely supporting his decisions. Even suggesting I work 3 jobs to support the "choices I made" instead of asking a man who didn't want the child to support it, instead of being a gold digger.

As you might guess I don't' see how giving this women my forgiveness benefits my child at this time.
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by Arinoaqua

Could we know his sign 🙇🏻‍♀️

sure..

Sun: Sag

Moon: Aqua

Merc: Sag

Venus: Scorpio

Mars: Cap
click to expand
A Sag man will usually do the right thing when it comes to his kids. Sag are very family orientated.

Even if it's like a hypothetical situation like him cheating on his wife, the girl getting pregnant and keeping the baby.

He will secretly meet up with the kid, as long as if doesn't interfere with his family life and doesn't become a threat.

But that's a different scenario and way more drama involved. 🥴
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by LadyNeptune
Posted by Astrobyn

Long story short, having contact with me interfered with his relationship (he choose after the fact), he didn’t want the responsibility of being a father to her, and then he moved 5 hours away.


Is he still in this relationship? Or did that end.

I honestly don't know, I assume he is, they might even be married by this point. I don't try to find out those things. I've made my wishes clear that it would be just him, which he's agreed to.

I would be very uncomfortable with my daughter being around that woman, she played a big part in helping him cultivate some fucked up ideas he had about me and the situation, and has completely supporting his decisions. Even suggesting I work 3 jobs to support the "choices I made" instead of asking a man who didn't want the child to support it, instead of being a gold digger.

As you might guess I don't' see how giving this women my forgiveness benefits my child at this time.
click to expand
Absolutely. She doesn't need anything from you, least of all your forgiveness.

I asked because it sounds like he let her convince him to chose her over his child. So if he is no longer in that relationship and now is talking about being part of your kids life... that would check out.

Ask him what his intentions are in wanting to meet her (or rather talking about wanting to meet her).

Is it to assuage his guilt over not being a part of her life?

Is it because he wants a relationship with her and what does that look like?

Ask him these things because I don't think he even knows what it is he wants. At this point the 4 year old probably has more healthy expectations then he does.

Posted by Astrobyn

I know she’s young but she’s always talked about him, when I’ve tried to brush it off and not make a big deal about it, she pushes harder about it.

The only reason I asked him, is because I she’s been talking a lot about him lately and we already had a trip planned to be in a meeting place.

My fear was that she would idealize him or have this fantasy about him, and I didn’t want that to happen and I wanted her to empowered with all the knowledge and information as she grows into understanding this.

But I am second guessing myself a year later, she does have a Pisces Moon, and it is like she lives in a dual world of reality and imagination.
As a Pisces moon 🌙 😂.....

It’s not actually a dual world of reality and imagination (imo). What it feels like, is imagining something better than what’s there. As if everyone and everything can be improved and made better...it’s a creative outlet when the world is too structured and “real”. There is no escapism > the fantasy world is based on reality and what isn’t working.

I actually may have been the only person to not idealize my father. My siblings still to this day idealize him in every way. I also am proud of him and I think he’s an amazing dad and grandpa but I’ve been the first kid to call him out on his behaviour since I was very little (not sure if that an Aries thing or just being a bitch from birth 😂).

As a Pisces moon I hate it when people try to escape the emotions of a situation tho. It makes me want to deep dive in the emotions and explore the WHY 😝
Alright I’ve thought about this some more

Saw you mentioned he’s a Sag with Aqua moon and that’s my bff too

She’s very hard in the way she expresses herself and can come across really very cold and uncaring but she actually just rarely says what’s she really *feels* ...she has no problem giving her opinion but she’s bad at expressing her feelings/emotions.

She also married a Pisces moon

Wondering if your baby daddy feels it’s too late for them, he’s already lost the time with her, and maybe it’s better he stay away at this point. Which is why he asked if you thought it would harm her to meet him.

I think it’s good that you relayed to him that she talks about him often and that you are supportive of them having a relationship.

I’m interested in hearing how he responds
Posted by brianafay

Alright I’ve thought about this some more

Saw you mentioned he’s a Sag with Aqua moon and that’s my bff too

She’s very hard in the way she expresses herself and can come across really very cold and uncaring but she actually just rarely says what’s she really *feels* ...she has no problem giving her opinion but she’s bad at expressing her feelings/emotions.

She also married a Pisces moon

Wondering if your baby daddy feels it’s too late for them, he’s already lost the time with her, and maybe it’s better he stay away at this point. Which is why he asked if you thought it would harm her to meet him.

I think it’s good that you relayed to him that she talks about him often and that you are supportive of them having a relationship.

I’m interested in hearing how he responds

he did respond, and i read the first line "first of all", so im currently on a virtual hh for work. so i'm going to go back to it later. I'll keep you updated soon. its stressing me out.
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by brianafay

Alright I’ve thought about this some more

Saw you mentioned he’s a Sag with Aqua moon and that’s my bff too

She’s very hard in the way she expresses herself and can come across really very cold and uncaring but she actually just rarely says what’s she really *feels* ...she has no problem giving her opinion but she’s bad at expressing her feelings/emotions.

She also married a Pisces moon

Wondering if your baby daddy feels it’s too late for them, he’s already lost the time with her, and maybe it’s better he stay away at this point. Which is why he asked if you thought it would harm her to meet him.

I think it’s good that you relayed to him that she talks about him often and that you are supportive of them having a relationship.

I’m interested in hearing how he responds

he did respond, and i read the first line "first of all", so im currently on a virtual hh for work. so i'm going to go back to it later. I'll keep you updated soon. its stressing me out.
click to expand

😬😬😬😬I’m already like oh hell no 😅
Yeah i'm going to need to sit on this one before i respond...

@brianafay

Him:

First off it has been a while since we spoke about this and I apologize if I dont remember everything "rolling eyes". Second I was just mentioning that because its the right thing to do. There is no need for the book report.

Expectations are we can meet when the opportunity arises and go from there. I already said I was willing to do that. Remember a big part of why I pulled back on my involvement had to do with your actions. I am not going to deal with drama, I have had enough of that. We need to get along and at least make an attempt to work together if this will work. There's no need for "rolling eyes" or any of that as it is obvious you are expressing hostility and for no reason. We use to get along great, I have always enjoyed our time together and I have always kept my word when it had to do with us but since all this happened I feel like there's some hostility on your end.

I am choosing to meet her because 1. I am curious and 2. I feel its the right thing to do as long as we dont think it will do more harm than good. I am leaving that part up to you since you're her guardian.
Posted by Astrobyn

Yeah i'm going to need to sit on this one before i respond...

@brianafay

Him:

First off it has been a while since we spoke about this and I apologize if I dont remember everything "rolling eyes". Second I was just mentioning that because its the right thing to do. There is no need for the book report.

Expectations are we can meet when the opportunity arises and go from there. I already said I was willing to do that. Remember a big part of why I pulled back on my involvement had to do with your actions. I am not going to deal with drama, I have had enough of that. We need to get along and at least make an attempt to work together if this will work. There's no need for "rolling eyes" or any of that as it is obvious you are expressing hostility and for no reason. We use to get along great, I have always enjoyed our time together and I have always kept my word when it had to do with us but since all this happened I feel like there's some hostility on your end.

I am choosing to meet her because 1. I am curious and 2. I feel its the right thing to do as long as we dont think it will do more harm than good. I am leaving that part up to you since you're her guardian.

He sounds like a real douche

I already responded in my head “ya know, on second thought, I’ll just send her your way when she’s old enough to ask you herself why you’re such a douche and you can explain, toodles”
First
Previous
Next
Last